Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

Supreme Court Suspends Life Terms of Two Bilkis Bano Case Convicts, Grants Bail

The order is dated 28 October and was widely reported on 16 November. Bilkis Bano said she was not heard and will fight it.

21 outlets36 headlines2 min read
Image: Verdictum

The story

Two men convicted in the Bilkis Bano case have spent more than 17 years in jail. Citing that and other grounds, the Supreme Court suspended their life sentences and granted them bail.

  • A special CBI court in Mumbai convicted 11 men on 21 January 2008. All got life terms. The Bombay High Court upheld this on 4 May 2017.
  • Gujarat remitted all 11 sentences in August 2022. The Supreme Court quashed that remission in January 2024, and the men went back to jail.
  • Two of them, Bipinchand Kanaiyalal Joshi and Pradip Ramanlal Modhiya, appealed the 2017 ruling. Justices M.M. Sundresh and Prasanna B. Varale heard them.
  • The bench cited more than 17 years in custody and a “severe handicap” for one man. It said the appeal raises issues “both on fact and law,” Verdictum reported.
  • Additional Solicitor General Raja Thakre opposed bail, ANI reported.
  • The order is dated 28 October. It went up on the court website on 15 November, The Wire reported.
  • Bilkis Bano said through her lawyer: “I will fight this order. I must.” She said she learned of it through press reports, Outlook reported.
  • The appeal against the convictions is still pending.

How each side told it

Left-leaning outlets led with Bilkis Bano and the case history. The Wire ran: “In ‘Pain, Shock, Disbelief’, Says Bilkis Bano.” It put her complaint about not being heard near the top. Its news report opened with the 2024 quashing of remission. In paragraph 6 it added that the 2022 remission had Union Home Ministry approval. It gave the bail grounds in paragraph 7. Deccan Herald's headline named the crimes: “two convicted of rape, murder.” Scroll's headline opened with “Bilkis Bano gang rape case.”

Missing context

The reports we read do not name the provision the court used. The general rule for suspending a sentence during an appeal is Section 389(1) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, now Section 430(1) of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023. It says the appellate court may, “for reasons to be recorded by it in writing,” suspend a sentence and release the convict on bail. Its first proviso says that for offences punishable with death, life imprisonment or 10 years or more, the Public Prosecutor must get a chance to object in writing. Its second proviso lets the prosecutor apply to cancel the bail.

What got buried

The calendar sat low. The order is dated 28 October, yet most reports came out on 16 November. The Wire gave both dates in paragraph 3 of its news report. Outlook reported that Bilkis Bano's family left Gujarat around 2 or 3 November, after the order. A defence point also went missing. The News Minute alone reported, in paragraph 6, the argument that she did not name the two men in her police statement. In the 8 reports we read, only The News Minute said Gujarat and Maharashtra also opposed bail.

Why it matters to you

This case shows how long appeals can take. The High Court ruled in May 2017. The two men reached the Supreme Court in March 2026, The Wire reported. That is nearly 9 years between rulings. The court tied bail to the 17 years already served. The law lets an appeals court suspend a sentence while the appeal runs. In life-term cases, the prosecutor must first get a chance to object. The state did object here. Bilkis Bano said she was not heard. If you follow a case, check the court website, since this order sat there before the news.

The date on an order matters as much as its words.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.