Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

INDIA Bloc Asks Supreme Court to Let It Put 48 Questions to Election Commission on SIR

Rahul Gandhi and other opposition leaders want named EC officials to answer under oath. The EC says its SIR orders were unanimous.

21 outlets31 headlines2 min read
Image: LawBeat

The story

Opposition leaders filed 48 questions in the Supreme Court on 16 November. Many ask one thing: did all three election commissioners agree to the nationwide SIR?

  • Rahul Gandhi and other INDIA bloc leaders filed the application on Monday, 16 November, ThePrint reported. It sits inside their pending petition against the Election Commission.
  • They want the court's leave to serve 48 interrogatories. These are written questions answered on oath.
  • The questions target CEC Gyanesh Kumar, Election Commissioners Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi, and other officials, ThePrint reported.
  • One asks how often Sandhu or Joshi recorded dissent on SIR or Form 6, The Pioneer reported.
  • The EC has said its SIR orders followed unanimous decisions. Its affidavits of 26 October and 14 November say so. Deputy EC Bhanu Prakash Yeturu affirmed both, ThePrint reported.
  • The petitioners cite an RTI reply. It said the Commission had “not taken any decision” on a nationwide SIR in 2025, The Wire reported.
  • On 14 November, the EC told the court that voters re-enrolling through Form 6 will not be prosecuted for that alone, PTI reported.
  • Outlets gave different head counts for the petitioners. ThePrint said 10 leaders joined Rahul Gandhi, and LawBeat said 13 leaders in all.

How each side told it

Left-leaning outlets led with the question of who decided. Deccan Herald ran: “‘Who decided to conduct SIR across the country?’” The Wire's headline put Rahul Gandhi's claim first: “No Material Evidence to Show SIR Was EC's ‘Unanimous’ Decision.” Its follow-up a day later opened with the EC's resistance. In paragraph 15 it cited an Indian Express report that two commissioners objected “14 times in 10 months.” Outlook asked: “Who Approved SIR?” The Wire did not explain what interrogatories are in the version we read.

Missing context

The petitioners cite Section 18(2) of the Chief Election Commissioner and Other Election Commissioners Act, 2023. It says: “All business of the Election Commission shall, as far as possible, be transacted unanimously.” If members differ, the matter “shall be decided according to the opinion of the majority.” So the law allows a majority decision as well as a unanimous one. Whether the SIR orders were unanimous is the factual question the 48 interrogatories ask.

What got buried

Two details sat low. The first is who swore the EC's affidavits. Deputy EC Yeturu did, and no commissioner filed one personally. ThePrint said so in paragraph 4. The Wire and The Pioneer did not name him in the versions we read. The second is the Form 6 promise. In the interrogatories stories we read, none mentioned it. PTI's own Form 6 copy placed the EC's unanimity defence in paragraph 12 of 13.

Why it matters to you

If your name was missing from a SIR draft roll, the Form 6 point touches you most. The EC said no one will be prosecuted only because they were enrolled before. Two conditions apply. You must not be enrolled in another constituency. Your declaration must otherwise follow the law. The fear was prosecution under Section 31 of the RP Act 1950, PTI reported. Voters can also apply online with e-sign on ECINET, the EC said. The bench later set 9 December to weigh the EC's objections to the questions, Free Press Journal reported. Check your name on the draft roll first.

Who signs an affidavit tells you who will answer for it.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.