Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

Sonia Gandhi Launches Memoir 'Belonging' as Publisher Reports 2 Lakh Copies Sold

INDIA bloc leaders and BJP's Amarinder Singh attended the Delhi launch. A BJP spokesperson called the event a self-goal.

23 outlets93 headlines2 min read
Image: National Herald

The story

HarperCollins India said Sonia Gandhi's memoir sold over two lakh copies in under a week. At its formal launch in Delhi on 16 November, a BJP leader sat among the guests.

  • The book went on sale on Tuesday, 10 November. HarperCollins India published it after Penguin Random House India dropped out, The Week reported.
  • The formal launch took place at ITC Maurya in New Delhi on Monday, 16 November.
  • HarperCollins India CEO Ananth Padmanabhan put sales at “over two lakh copies,” India.com reported.
  • Sonia Gandhi said she wrote it because much written about her family was untrue. “Most of it is quite unreal,” she said, The Week reported.
  • Rahul Gandhi spoke about his parents. He recalled the only fight he saw between them, which began with a phone call to Amarinder Singh, The Tribune reported.
  • Guests included Mallikarjun Kharge, Akhilesh Yadav, Abhishek Banerjee, Tamil Nadu CM Vijay and BJP's Amarinder Singh, PTI reported.
  • BJP spokesperson C R Kesavan called the launch a “highly damaging self-goal,” PTI reported.
  • The sales figure comes from the publisher. The reports we read don't say how it was counted.

How each side told it

Left-leaning outlets led with Sonia Gandhi's own words. National Herald ran: “‘The dam burst’: Sonia Gandhi at official launch of memoir.” It gave her motive in paragraph 1. It placed the BJP's “whitewashing” charge in paragraph 17, the last, with no name attached. The Wire's video headline took a side on sales: “The BJP Is Helping It Sell.” Deccan Herald led with the guest list and named Vijay and Amarinder Singh in its headline. None of the left headlines in our list carried the two lakh sales figure.

Missing context

One headline, ThePrint's “Sonia Gandhi's father, the Holocaust and the history her book chooses to forget,” turns on a historical claim. Its author, Praveen Swami, wrote that Stefano Maino served as an Italian soldier near Dnepropetrovsk, where Jews were massacred in October 1941. Yad Vashem's record of that site says over 10,000 Jews were killed on 13 to 15 October 1941. It names the killers as an SS squad, Police Battalion 314 and local auxiliary police, and names no Italian unit. Swami himself wrote that the archives will not settle whether Maino took part.

What got buried

The BJP leader in the room got little space. Amarinder Singh's own words came through in one report we read. He told Oneindia: “I have simply come here for a social event.” PTI's launch story named him in paragraph 4. IANS named him in its last paragraph, 16. India.com and ETV Bharat left him out. The criticism sat low too. National Herald and PTI's launch story placed the BJP's charge in their final paragraphs. In the 11 reports we read, only PTI's separate story named Kesavan.

Why it matters to you

Sales opened at 10 am on 10 November, India.com reported. Two lakh copies in under 7 days is nearly 29,000 a day on average. That means many readers will meet her account of events first. Critics have started checking it. Organiser disputed dates in the book. ThePrint's Praveen Swami wrote about what it leaves out on her father. Kesavan said the timing before state polls showed political opportunism, PTI reported. You can read the book next to its critics and check the dates yourself. Publisher figures and party statements both deserve a second source.

A memoir is a source, and every source needs a second.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.