Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

Grand jury declines to indict Jan. 6 witness Cassidy Hutchinson

A Washington grand jury rejected the Justice Department's bid to charge the former Trump aide over her 2022 testimony, sources told AP and Fox News.

18 outlets18 headlines2 min read
Image: ABC News (via ABC30)

The story

Grand juries almost never refuse an indictment, because prosecutors need only show probable cause, Fox News reported. On Oct. 27, a Washington grand jury refused to charge Cassidy Hutchinson.

  • Hutchinson was an aide to Trump's chief of staff, Mark Meadows. She testified to the House Jan. 6 committee on June 28, 2022.
  • She said Trump grabbed the steering wheel of his SUV on Jan. 6, 2021. She said she heard this from another official and was not there, AP reported.
  • In March 2024, House Republicans released a transcript from the Secret Service driver. He said Trump "never grabbed the steering wheel," AP reported.
  • Republican lawmakers accused her of lying under oath. The Justice Department's Civil Rights Division brought the case, Fox News reported.
  • On Tuesday, the grand jury rejected it. A department lawyer told the court the jury returned a "non-concurrence," Fox reported.
  • AP and Fox each cited two people familiar with the matter. ABC News said The Washington Post reported the news first.
  • Hutchinson says she stands by her testimony. The Justice Department did not comment in the reports we read.
  • Prosecutors could try again. Fox said the decision "does not establish" whether her testimony was true or false.

How each side told it

The left framed the vote as a loss for the department. ABC News ran: "DOJ fails to get indictment against former Trump aide Cassidy Hutchinson." Its fourth paragraph called it "the latest setback." The same paragraph cited critics who see "a campaign of retribution." CBS News called her a "Trump critic" in its headline. NBC News called her the "star witness of Jan. 6 committee." ABC put the disputed steering wheel story in paragraph 5. It did not mention the 2024 driver transcript in the version we read.

What got buried

Two details sat low. The first is that the driver backed part of her account. AP said in paragraph 10 that his transcript supported other parts, including Trump's attempt to join the Capitol crowd. In the 3 reports we read, only AP said so. The second is doubt inside the department. CNN reported that some officials thought the evidence was not enough, Fox's report said in paragraph 5. ABC News carried neither detail in the version we read.

Why it matters to you

A grand jury usually has 16 to 23 members, the Washington Examiner reported, per Fox's report. Prosecutors need only probable cause to win an indictment, Fox said. This case did not clear that bar. The same check stands between any citizen and a federal felony charge. If you are ever called for grand jury duty, your vote counts toward that check. This case may come back. A refusal does not stop prosecutors from trying again with another grand jury, Fox reported. Watch for whether the department files again.

A grand jury's no measures the evidence on the table.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.