Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

Trump says he is ending the Biden-era methane rule for oil and gas wells

At a Texas rally, Trump said the rollback would save $45 billion. His EPA chief has put the rule's cost at $18 billion.

14 outlets18 headlines2 min read
Image: Fox Business

The story

Trump said ending a Biden-era methane rule would save $45 billion. His own EPA chief, Lee Zeldin, has said the rule would cost $18 billion, AP reported.

  • Trump spoke at a rally in Lubbock, Texas, on Tuesday, Oct. 27.
  • He said: "Tonight, I'm officially terminating Biden's expensive and unnecessary methane regulations," Fox Business reported.
  • He said the change would save consumers and producers $45 billion. He said it would unlock 210 million barrels of oil. AP said that is about 10 days of U.S. petroleum use.
  • Zeldin previewed the plan in September. It would end the "Super Emitter Program," which makes companies find and fix big leaks. It would also ease standards for small wells.
  • The Biden rule was finalized in 2024. It was the first to cover existing wells as well as new ones, AP reported.
  • Biden officials said it would prevent about 58 million tons of methane by 2038. They projected $98 billion in benefits by 2034. Trump's EPA rejects the method behind that figure, AP said.
  • Environmental groups criticized the move. Fred Krupp of the Environmental Defense Fund said "EPA should be fighting this waste," Fox Business reported.
  • The reports we read don't explain the gap between $45 billion and $18 billion.

How each side told it

The left led with climate. The Washington Post ran AP's headline about "climate-warming methane from oil drilling." The New York Times called methane "a Potent Warming Gas" in its headline. Politico tied the news to the campaign: "Trump debuts oil rule rollback as Texas wobbles toward blue." The AP story the Post ran put climate science in paragraph 4. It quoted an environmental lawyer in paragraph 10. Zeldin's $18 billion came in paragraph 11. Neither the Times nor the Politico headline named a dollar figure.

What got buried

The cost gap sat low on both sides. Trump said $45 billion in savings. Zeldin has said $18 billion in costs. In the 2 reports we read, only AP gave both numbers, in paragraphs 2 and 11. Fox Business gave only the $45 billion. A second detail went missing too. Small wells produce 6% of U.S. oil and gas, AP said in paragraph 16. They make up to half of the methane from oil and gas fields. The rollback eases rules on those small wells.

Why it matters to you

The $45 billion has no time frame in the reports we read. Zeldin's $18 billion has none either. Without one, you cannot tell how much might reach your energy bills. Some numbers do come with dates. The 210 million barrels equal about 10 days of U.S. use, AP said. The Biden rule's $98 billion in benefits covered the years to 2034. A lawyer told AP the change would put "a heavier pollution burden" on front-line communities. When a savings number has no year count, ask for one.

A savings number without a time frame cannot be checked.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.