Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

Trump rallies for Paxton in Texas and greets a tanker of Venezuelan oil

Trump and Democrat James Talarico held rival rallies in Lubbock a week before Election Day. Trump also called a Venezuelan oil cargo a gift.

26 outlets62 headlines3 min read
Image: Fox News

The story

Trump told Texans a tanker of 1 million barrels of Venezuelan oil was a "gift." U.S. refiners process about 17 million barrels a day, Newsweek reported, so the cargo covers about 6% of one day.

  • On Tuesday, Oct. 27, Trump campaigned in Texas for Republican Senate candidate Ken Paxton. Election Day was one week away.
  • His first stop was a tanker of Venezuelan crude in Texas. Trump said Venezuela sent him "a boatload of a million barrels of oil" as a gift, Newsweek reported.
  • A White House official told Reuters the government got the oil "at no cost." The seller, NABEP, first said the cargo came under a U.S. right to buy 20% of its output at cost. NABEP later updated its statement to say the cargo came at no cost to taxpayers.
  • The U.S. government will sell the crude to Exxon Mobil and Citgo refineries, Reuters reported.
  • That night, Trump rallied in Lubbock. Talarico, the Democrat, held his own rally about four miles away, Fox News reported. Fox put Talarico's crowd at about 4,000 people.
  • Fox said polls show Talarico narrowly ahead of Paxton. It gave no poll numbers.
  • Regular gas averaged $4.27 a gallon on Tuesday, AAA said, per Newsweek. That was down from $4.48 a month earlier and up from $3.05 a year earlier.
  • The reports we read don't say what the oil is worth or where the sale money goes.

How each side told it

The left led with the duel and with who paid. The Washington Post's headline ended: "The U.S. paid for it." That states as fact a point the Reuters report leaves open. The Guardian put Trump's "51st state" remark beside the oil in its headline. NBC News named Talarico first: "James Talarico faces off against Trump in dueling Texas rallies." The Post's AP headline also opened with Talarico's vow to "take back Texas." CBS News framed the trip around Paxton in a "tight" race. No left headline we saw gave the cargo's size next to daily U.S. use.

What got buried

Two details sat low. The first is the price of the "gift." In the 3 reports we read, only Reuters said NABEP first described the cargo as bought at cost. Reuters put this in paragraph 2. The Post's headline says the U.S. paid. The White House says it did not. The second detail is scale. Newsweek quoted Luisa Palacios of Columbia University calling the cargo "negligible" for U.S. refiners, in paragraph 8. No headline we saw on either side carried her view.

Why it matters to you

Gas was $4.27 a gallon on Tuesday and $3.05 a year earlier, AAA said. That is $1.22 more per gallon. If you buy 15 gallons a week, you pay about $18.30 more each week than last fall. Trump said prices will "come plummeting down." Palacios said the cargo is "unlikely to have any noticeable effect" on gas prices. Here is the math behind her view. At 17 million barrels a day, 1 million barrels covers about 1.4 hours of U.S. refining. When a leader names a barrel count, divide it by daily use.

A big number means little until you divide it by daily use.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.