Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

New Jersey cheese importer sues to stop Trump's 50% tariffs on Canadian goods

The suit says a 1930 law was replaced decades ago. Most outlets covered the legal fight and skipped what the tariff costs the company per shipment.

9 outlets10 headlines2 min read
Image: Reuters (via The Daily Record)

The story

One shipment of goat's milk cheese worth about $120,000 drew more than $60,000 in tariffs, Fox Business reported. On Oct. 20, the company that imported it sued to stop the duty.

  • Gellert Global Group, a family-run New Jersey food importer, filed the suit on Tuesday, Oct. 20. It went to the U.S. Court of International Trade in New York.
  • The Liberty Justice Center represents it. The same group won the Supreme Court case on emergency tariffs, AP and Reuters reported.
  • Trump's 50% tariff covers about $20 billion of Canadian goods, AP reported. It took effect Aug. 22, trade law firm ST&R reported. Cheese was added in September.
  • The tariff rests on Section 338 of the Tariff Act of 1930. AP said the law had never been tested in court.
  • The suit says later trade laws replaced Section 338. It asks the court to stop collection and refund duties with interest.
  • Gellert says it has paid at least $520,538 on 22 shipments since Sept. 16, Newsweek reported.
  • AP said the White House will "vigorously defend" the tariffs. Reuters said the White House did not immediately respond.
  • Reuters and Fox Business called this the fourth major challenge to Trump's tariffs.

How each side told it

The left barely covered it. The New York Times was the only left-leaning outlet in our list with a headline on the suit. It ran: "Trump Tariffs on Canada Spark Latest Lawsuit Over Trade Powers." That headline frames the case as one more fight over who sets tariffs. We could not open the Times article. So we cannot say what it put first, whom it quoted or what it left low. On this story, the left had one headline in our list. The right had four.

What got buried

The cost to the company sat low or nowhere. Fox Business led with Gellert's estimate of about $40 million a year. It put the zero duty under the US-Mexico-Canada trade deal in paragraph 7 and the cheese shipment in paragraph 8. Newsweek said in paragraph 15 that Gellert is absorbing costs for now and prices may rise. AP, Reuters, Bloomberg and both Reason pieces gave no cost figure for the company or for shoppers.

Why it matters to you

The math starts with Gellert's own numbers. $520,538 over 22 shipments is about $23,700 per shipment. The $40 million yearly estimate is about $770,000 a week. On a $10 import price, a 50% duty adds $5 before any store markup. Gellert is absorbing that for now, Newsweek reported, and prices may rise later. The last big tariff ruling ordered refunds of about $166 billion with interest, Bloomberg reported. The reports we read don't say whether shoppers would see any refund from this case.

A tariff rate means little until you see the invoice.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.