Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

Trump tells Kansas rally the US could burn like France if Democrats win

AP found no evidence tying immigrants to the French riots. Outlets split on what drives the unrest and on whether to say so.

11 outlets14 headlines2 min read
Image: Fox News

The story

Kansas has not elected a Democrat to the US Senate in 94 years, Reuters reported. At a rally there on Oct. 19, President Trump used France's riots to warn voters about Democrats.

  • Trump spoke on Monday, Oct. 19, in Park City, Kansas, near Wichita. The rally backed Republican Sen. Roger Marshall.
  • He described "burning steeples and raging fires," Reuters reported. He said that is what "the radical Dumocrats want to do to America," in Reuters' version.
  • He told the crowd, "Close your border or you will lose France," Fox News reported.
  • Reuters wrote there is no evidence for his claim. It said protests over living costs and underfunded public services turned violent.
  • AP said at least 3,000 shops were damaged or looted. AP also said "Authorities and police have not linked immigrants" to the rioting.
  • French officials blamed far-left groups, Fox News and AP reported. France's justice minister said 2,513 people were taken into custody, Fox reported.
  • Marshall faces Democrat Adam Hamilton, a Methodist pastor. Cook rates the race a toss-up, Newsweek reported.
  • The reports we read do not show a Democrat answering the France claim directly.

How each side told it

The left led with the warning itself. The New Republic ran: "Trump Warns America Will Burn if Republicans Lose This Election." It quoted only Trump. It called the French unrest "student protests" and gave no causes. Its writer called the claims "invented" and "desperate" in paragraph 7. Politico ran: "Trump says US will 'burn' like France if 'radical Democrats' come to power." It also ran a second piece on Republicans finding "a closing message in Paris riots." We could not open the Politico articles, so we judged them by headline.

What got buried

AP's fact-check carried the detail most others left out. The "burning steeples" image showed a town hall bell tower in Limoges, AP reported in paragraphs 14 to 19. No houses of worship were directly attacked, it said. A Paris synagogue was damaged in a likely burglary. Reuters, The New Republic, Newsweek and Fox all repeated the steeples line without this. AP also said in paragraph 11 that France does not collect ethnicity data on people arrested.

Why it matters to you

The rally was about France. The prices were in Kansas. Reuters reported gas at $3.98 and diesel at $5.78 a gallon at a Park City truck stop. Diesel was about 45% higher than a year earlier, per AAA. At those prices, a 20-gallon diesel fill costs about $116, against about $80 a year ago. That is roughly $36 more per tank. Reuters put these numbers in paragraphs 22 and 23, below the France lines. Hamilton's spokesperson pointed to the same prices. You can weigh both claims against the numbers in the reports.

A photo without a caption can carry any argument.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.