Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

Trump uses 'Shylock' slur while defending Sen. Marshall's lawsuits against patients

Nine outlets in our list ran headlines on the remark, none from the right. The patient lawsuits behind it, and 81 arrests, sat low almost everywhere.

9 outlets9 headlines2 min read Blindspot for the right
Image: Fox News

The story

President Trump used the word "Shylock" at a Kansas rally on Oct. 19, CNN reported. He was defending Sen. Roger Marshall, whose medical practice sued more than 700 patients.

  • Trump spoke in Park City, Kansas, on Monday, Oct. 19. The rally backed Marshall, a doctor, before the Nov. 3 midterms.
  • He said critics "made it like, oh, he was some kind of a Shylock-type guy," CNN reported.
  • The ADL said the term can "reinforce harmful tropes about Jews," CNN reported.
  • The remark followed a New York Times report from September. It found Marshall's practice sued more than 700 patients over unpaid bills. Patients were arrested in 81 cases for missing court dates. Many were charged 18% yearly interest.
  • Marshall called the Times story a "hit job," NBC reported.
  • Trump said Marshall had to sue "by law." HuffPost cited the Kansas City Star, which found no law requires doctors to sue patients over medical debt.
  • Trump used the term in July 2025 too. He later said he had "never heard it that way."
  • The White House did not immediately respond, NBC reported.

How each side told it

The left led with the word. CNN ran: "Trump uses antisemitic term 'Shylock'" and named the patient lawsuits in the same headline. It put the 700 lawsuits in paragraph 2 and a Georgetown law professor in paragraph 4. The Daily Beast called it a "Vile Slur" and Marshall a "Floundering MAGA Senator." The New Republic said Trump "Casually Tosses Out a Slur." HuffPost led with a different angle, Trump's false legal claim. CNN, HuffPost and The New Republic did not give the 81 arrests in the versions we read.

What got buried

Both sides put the patients low. NBC reached the arrest warrants in paragraph 8, after the 2025 history and an ADL definition. In the nine reports we read, CNN, HuffPost and The New Republic left out the 81 arrests. KCUR reported that the Kansas City Star found no other provider charging more than 12% interest. One more detail sat last: the ADL did not name Trump this time. Only the Times of Israel, in its final paragraph, and KCUR said so.

Why it matters to you

The numbers behind the slur touch anyone with a medical bill. At 18% a year, a $2,000 debt grows by $360 in one year. At 12%, the highest rate the Star found elsewhere, it grows by $240. That is $120 more a year at 18%. The Star found no law requiring doctors to sue patients. Patients in 81 of these cases were arrested after missing court dates, the Times reported. If you get a court notice over a medical debt, go to the hearing.

The loudest word in a story often hides its biggest number.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.