Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

Zelenskyy says Starshield speed limits weaken Ukraine's defence of its power grid

Zelenskyy asked SpaceX and the US to lift the limits. SpaceX told Axios nothing had changed, a denial AP's story left out.

10 outlets11 headlines2 min read
Image: Al Jazeera

The story

Russia launched more than 2,300 drones, 1,590 guided bombs and 15 missiles at Ukraine in one week, Zelenskyy said on Nov 15. He said satellite speed limits let more of them get through.

  • Starshield is the military version of SpaceX's Starlink network. Ukraine says terminals over occupied areas are capped at 161 km/h (100 mph), the Kyiv Independent reported.
  • On Nov 13, Zelenskyy said the cap had been in place for five days. He said SpaceX called it a technical problem, and he rejected that.
  • SpaceX told Axios: “This is false. There has been no change,” the Kyiv Independent reported.
  • In October, Elon Musk wrote that limits are “decided by the US military and ultimately POTUS,” Fox News reported.
  • On Nov 15, Zelenskyy wrote: “We are counting on these restrictions to be lifted,” AP reported. He added: “It is important to be on the right side of history.”
  • A Russian strike near Odesa left about 41,000 customers without power, AP reported.
  • The reports we read don't settle who imposed the current limit or why.

How each side told it

Al Jazeera ran: “Starshield restrictions help Russia's energy attacks on Ukraine: Zelenskyy.” Its subheadline carried the SpaceX denial and Musk's view that the US military could be behind the limits. In the body, the denial came in paragraph 7. The Washington Post ran AP's version, which named neither Musk nor the denial. CBC put Zelenskyy's appeal in its headline: “'Be on the right side of history'.” The left put the request on top and the fight over who did it lower.

What got buried

SpaceX's denial sat low or went missing. SpaceX told Axios there had been “no change.” AP left it out in both versions we read. Al Jazeera had it in paragraph 7. The Kyiv Independent also had it in paragraph 7. Among the Nov 15 reports we read, only Al Jazeera carried Musk's earlier view that the US military and the president set the limits. So readers of AP's story saw one side of a two-sided dispute.

Why it matters to you

This lands on Ukrainian homes as winter starts. About 41,000 customers near Odesa lost power after one strike, AP reported. Ukraine's army said it downed 106 of 132 Russian drones overnight, Al Jazeera reported. That leaves 26 not shot down, about 1 in 5. Zelenskyy said slower links force Ukraine to shoot drones down “at other lines of defense.” Ukraine's Starshield contract runs until May 15, 2027, Fox News reported in October. One honest limit: no source we read ties the cap to any specific hit.

A story missing one denial is missing one side.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.