Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

UK Prime Minister Burnham says 'Brexit has not worked' ahead of EU summit

Right-leaning outlets ran 13 headlines on the speech, left-leaning ones ran 3. Burnham kept Labour's red lines on the single market and customs union.

9 outlets22 headlines2 min read Blindspot for the left
Image: The Guardian (via AOL)

The story

UK Prime Minister Andy Burnham planned to say “The Brexit we were given has not worked,” Reuters reported on Nov 15. In our list, right-leaning outlets ran 13 headlines on it and left-leaning ones ran 3.

  • Burnham gave the speech at the Lord Mayor's Banquet in the City of London on Monday, Nov 16. Reuters released extracts a day earlier.
  • He planned to say: “We have lost more than we gained.” He compared silence on Brexit to the Emperor's new clothes.
  • He set three conditions for any deal, the Evening Standard and Sky reported. First, it must stay inside Labour's red lines: no single market, customs union or free movement.
  • Second, it must move Brexit closer to what voters expected in 2016. Third, it must bring “real, tangible improvements in people's everyday lives.”
  • The EU summit in Brussels is on Friday, Nov 20. Expected deals cover food border checks, emissions trading and youth mobility.
  • Burnham said the summit deals would add 0.4% to GDP. The Independent and the Standard gave no outside check of that figure.
  • Conservative deputy leader Alex Burghart said Burnham was “reopening a debate the country settled long ago,” the Standard reported.

How each side told it

Only one left-leaning outlet in our list, The Independent, ran this story. Its headline: “Burnham hits out at Brexit failure as crunch EU summit looms.” It opened with Burnham's attack on “Boris Johnson's Brexit deal.” It quoted no one except Burnham. The 0.4% GDP claim came in paragraph 11, with no outside check. The Guardian's later piece, which we also read, put the venue in paragraph 10. It quoted an EU lawmaker, Sandro Gozi, in paragraphs 17 and 18.

What got buried

The red lines got less space than the slogan. Burnham kept Labour's ban on rejoining the single market, customs union or free movement, Reuters reported in paragraphs 7 and 8. Reuters said those lines bind him until 2029. The Telegraph headline still called it a “plot to rejoin the EU.” The Guardian reported that options after the next election include fully rejoining. One more detail ran only in the Express: either side pays compensation if it pulls out of the food deal. The Express gave no size for it.

Why it matters to you

Every money figure in this story is an estimate. Burnham said the summit deals would add 0.4% to GDP. The Guardian put that at about £17bn and named no source. Burnham also said Brexit cost 4% to 8% of GDP, AP reported, with no source given. The Telegraph op-ed cited a 2020 Office for Budget Responsibility forecast of 4% lower GDP in the long run. That op-ed also cited a report saying rejoining would leave each person £2,800 worse off in 10 years. Reuters said the summit deals could lower costs for shoppers in the short term. Ask each side to name its source.

Count the headlines, then count the sources.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.