Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

Supreme Court suspends sentences of two Bilkis Bano convicts, she says she was not heard

The bench cited over 17 years in jail and one man's disability. Bilkis Bano and her family have left Gujarat, and she plans to challenge the order.

15 outlets25 headlines3 min read
Image: Asianet Newsable (ANI)

The story

Two men serving life terms in the 2002 Bilkis Bano case got bail after more than 17 years in jail. Bilkis Bano said she learnt of it through press reports.

  • A Supreme Court bench of Justices M.M. Sundresh and Prasanna B. Varale suspended the life sentences of two convicts, PTI reported. Most outlets dated the order 28 October. Scroll gave 12 October. ThePrint reported it was uploaded on 15 November.
  • The convicts are Bipin Chandra Joshi and Pradeep Mordhiya. Spellings vary by outlet.
  • The order said they had been jailed "for a period of more than seventeen years." It said one appellant "has a severe handicap." The court left bail conditions to the trial court, PTI reported.
  • Their appeal against a 2017 Bombay High Court ruling is still pending, ThePrint reported. Suspension does not overturn their convictions, National Herald reported. Gujarat opposed bail in court.
  • Bilkis Bano said "I am scared once again" and "I will fight this order," Outlook reported. Her uncle said the family left Gujarat around 2 or 3 November.
  • Congress's Pawan Khera and CPI(M)'s M.A. Baby criticised the order. The reports we read carried no BJP statement.
  • Reports differ on how many of her family members were killed in 2002: seven or 14.

How each side told it

The left led with Bilkis Bano's fear and the case history. National Herald ran: "Bilkis Bano expresses shock at SC suspending sentence of two rapists." It quoted her first. Khera came in paragraph 5 and Baby in paragraph 6. Scroll's first report quoted the bench first and gave no reaction from Bilkis. It spent paragraphs 5 to 10 on the 2024 ruling that found the 2022 release was obtained by fraud. The Hindu headlined the politics: "Opposition questions Supreme Court order in Bilkis Bano case." Neither National Herald report we read quoted a BJP leader.

What got buried

Bilkis Bano said the order came "without hearing me." ThePrint explained why in paragraph 4: she "was not made a party to the suspension application." In paragraph 3 it said the appeal has been pending since 2017. The bail application was filed only this year. In the 12 reports we read, only ThePrint carried the party detail. Another fact sat out of view. In July 2024 a different bench refused interim bail to two other convicts. It called those pleas "absolutely misconceived," Scroll reported at the time.

Why it matters to you

This order shows how one bench weighed time served against a slow appeal. The numbers are 17 years in jail and an appeal open since 2017. That is about nine years without a final ruling. A suspended sentence means release while the appeal runs. The convictions stand, National Herald reported. Bilkis Bano's lawyer, Shobha Gupta, released her statement, and she said she will challenge the order. ThePrint's report holds a practical point for anyone in a long appeal. Ask whether you are a party to every application. That decides whether you get heard.

Who gets heard depends on who is named in the filing.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.