Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

Supreme Court sets 9 December hearing on INDIA bloc's 48 questions to Election Commission

The bench will hear the EC's objections before deciding. Outlets split on whether the court sought the EC's reply or declined to issue notice.

11 outlets16 headlines2 min read
Image: LiveLaw

The story

Opposition leaders want the Election Commission to answer 48 written questions about the voter roll revision. On 17 November the Supreme Court put that decision off to 9 December.

  • Chief Justice Surya Kant, Justice Joymalya Bagchi and Justice V Mohana took up the case on 17 November, PTI reported.
  • The application, led by Rahul Gandhi, asks to serve 48 written questions, called interrogatories, on the Election Commission. Other petitioners include Mallikarjun Kharge, Akhilesh Yadav, Tejashwi Yadav and Sanjay Raut, LiveLaw reported.
  • The court adjourned the case because a part-heard matter was taken up first, PTI reported. The Chief Justice said the court would hear the questions plea "and then will take a call."
  • For the EC, Harish Salve said the questions would cause "very serious prejudice," Bar & Bench reported. Kapil Sibal asked the court to issue notice.
  • The main question is whether the Chief Election Commissioner used the Commission's powers without the other two commissioners, PTI reported. In a 248-page reply, the EC said all three SIR orders were unanimous.
  • LiveLaw corrected an earlier version of its report that said the court had sought the EC's response.

How each side told it

Left outlets framed the hearing as a request to the EC. National Herald ran: "SC seeks EC's response to 48 questions by INDIA bloc leaders before 9 Dec." Deccan Herald's headline said the court "asks Election Commission to reply." LiveLaw later corrected that same framing in its own report. National Herald did not report the EC's arguments in court. The Wire led with the EC's side: "Election Commission Strongly Resists Answering 48 Questions." It quoted Salve first. It also carried details we found nowhere else, including WhatsApp messages in paragraph 8.

What got buried

The case grew from a news report. On 25 September the Indian Express reported that Election Commissioners Sandhu and Joshi objected to SIR orders. It said the orders were issued "without their knowledge or recommendation." PTI put this in its last paragraph, 18. The Wire put it in paragraph 14. Also low: an August 2025 RTI reply said no decision on a nationwide SIR had been taken, Bar & Bench reported in paragraph 10. Both details explain why the petitioners want written answers.

Why it matters to you

The SIR decides whose name sits on the roll you vote from. The EC's affidavit lists three SIR orders, dated 24 June 2025, 27 October 2025 and 14 May 2026. The petitioners ask whether all three commissioners agreed to them. If the court allows the questions, the EC would have to answer them in writing. The next date is 9 December, 22 days after this hearing. The 17 November order changed no voter roll. Deccan Chronicle reported that five poll-bound states have released draft rolls. You can check your own entry while objections are open.

The same order can read as a request or a refusal.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.