Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

POCSO case filed against Jharkhand Congress MLA Bhushan Bara, who calls it a conspiracy

Ranchi police registered an FIR after a 14-year-old girl's complaint. Right-leaning outlets ran 11 headlines on it. We found none from the left.

9 outlets15 headlines2 min read Blindspot for the left
Image: Asianet Newsable (ANI)

The story

Police in Ranchi registered a case under the POCSO Act against Jharkhand Congress MLA Bhushan Bara on 13 November. Of 15 headlines on it, 11 came from right-leaning outlets and none from the left.

  • The FIR was filed at the Vidhan Sabha police station in Ranchi, Republic and ANI reported. Bara is the MLA for Simdega.
  • It was registered under the POCSO Act and the Juvenile Justice Act, Hatia DSP Niraj Kumar said. The complainant is a 14-year-old tribal girl.
  • She alleges she was brought to Ranchi with a promise of schooling, made to do housework and raped, the reports said. None of the reports we read gave section numbers.
  • Police have begun an investigation, ANI reported. No report we read mentioned an arrest.
  • Bara called the case "completely fabricated," Republic reported. He said political opponents were behind it.
  • BJP state chief Aditya Sahu demanded his arrest, UNI reported. Congress's Rakesh Sinha said "there can't be two sets of laws" and sought an impartial probe. JMM's Manoj Pandey said, "We neither protect anyone nor frame anyone."
  • Indian Express and NDTV headlines mentioned a forced abortion. The reports we read did not describe one.

How each side told it

We found no headline on this case from any left-leaning outlet in our set. That includes The Hindu, Scroll, The Wire, Deccan Herald, The Telegraph, Outlook and National Herald. A search of those sites for 13 and 14 November also came up empty. Absence from our list does not prove they ignored it, since some may have covered it later or in print. Center outlets did run it. The Indian Express ran: "Minor accuses Jharkhand Congress MLA of sexual assault, forced abortion." NDTV wrote of "Allegations Of Raping 14-Year-Old Girl." We did not read either story in full.

No left-leaning outlet we read ran this story.

What got buried

Bara's full answer sat low or went missing. Republic carried it in paragraphs 7 to 9. He said the girl was one of many young people he and his wife help with schooling. He also said people expelled from his organisation coached her. In the 8 reports we read, only Republic gave these reasons. The police status sat low as well. ANI put the investigation line in its last paragraph. The DSP declined to share names.

Why it matters to you

Two sets of rights meet in this case. The complainant is 14. The BJP asked for security for her and her family, UNI reported. Bara is the accused, and he denies the charge. No court has ruled. For you as a reader, the coverage gap is the lesson. If you read only left-leaning sites, you may not have seen this case on 13 November. If you read only some right-leaning stories, you may have missed Bara's reply. What is established so far is short: an FIR, a POCSO case and an open investigation. Follow the police and court record from here.

Where a story is missing tells you as much as where it runs.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.