Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

Modi cites 4% yearly farm growth, says Centre absorbed Rs 43 of diesel price rise

Eight outlets covered the speech at an India Today Group event. None of the left-leaning outlets in our list ran it.

8 outlets31 headlines2 min read Blindspot for the left
Image: The Pioneer

The story

Prime Minister Narendra Modi said on 12 November that the Centre held a Rs 50 diesel rise down to Rs 7 a litre. He put the cost at about Rs 14,000 crore a month.

  • Modi spoke at the Kisan Tak Bharat Agriculture Conference, organised by the India Today Group, PTI reported.
  • He said farming grew more than 4% a year over the past decade. He called it the first such decade since Independence.
  • He cited a World Bank report that about 50 crore Indians left poverty in 12 to 13 years.
  • He said crude rose from $70 to $122 a barrel within weeks during the West Asia war. Diesel would have risen by about Rs 50 a litre, he said.
  • The government raised it by Rs 7, and the Centre absorbed Rs 43, he said.
  • He said a 50 kg DAP fertiliser bag costing about Rs 5,000 abroad was sold to farmers at Rs 1,300.
  • He urged farmers to grow more than wheat, rice and sugarcane, and to try natural farming.
  • The reports we read gave no independent check of the 4% figure.

How each side told it

Our list shows no left-leaning headline on this speech. That covers ten outlets, including Deccan Herald, The Hindu, The Telegraph, Scroll and The Wire. On the same day, the left covered prices from the other end. The Hindu carried Congress's line: "'Sab changa si' has become 'sab mehnga si'." The Telegraph ran: "Inflation hits two-year high as the price of everything goes up." So readers of the left saw the cost side of the farm story, without the government's diesel figures.

No left-leaning outlet we read ran this story.

What got buried

The cost of the diesel decision sat low. Modi said the government loses about Rs 14,000 crore a month on it, PTI reported in paragraph 14. The Pioneer gave it in paragraph 7. None of the headlines in our list carried that number. Over 12 months, Rs 14,000 crore a month would come to Rs 1.68 lakh crore. The reports we read don't say how long the policy will last. The 4% figure is a yearly average across ten years, both reports said.

Why it matters to you

Take a farmer who uses 100 litres of diesel a month. At Rs 7 a litre more, that costs Rs 700 extra. At the full Rs 50, it would be Rs 5,000 extra, by Modi's figures. The government covers the Rs 43 gap, at about Rs 14,000 crore a month, he said. The speech came on the same day retail inflation hit 6.09%, with food prices up 8.94% in a year, Swarajya reported. Both numbers land in the same kitchen. Read them together.

A price held down is a cost paid somewhere else.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.