Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

Karnataka and BJP MP dispute who pays for Bengaluru Metro ahead of Pink Line opening

Both sides used the same Rs 77,891 crore total. They put one Rs 28,958 crore loan line in different columns.

12 outlets18 headlines2 min read
Image: The News Minute

The story

Karnataka says it pays 84% of Bengaluru Metro's cost. BJP MP Tejasvi Surya says the Centre pays 54%. Both start from the same Rs 77,891 crore total.

  • On 11 November, Bengaluru Development Minister Krishna Byre Gowda said Karnataka bears about 84% of Metro costs, The News Minute reported.
  • He put the state's share at Rs 65,291 crore of Rs 77,891 crore. He said the Centre gives Rs 12,600 crore, PTI reported.
  • On 12 November, BJP MP Tejasvi Surya said the split is 54% Centre and 46% state, PTI reported. The News Minute put his figure at 53.35%.
  • Surya said the state counted Rs 28,958 crore in foreign loans as its own. He said the Centre guaranteed those loans.
  • He said BMRCL is a 50:50 joint venture, with each side putting in Rs 9,164 crore of equity.
  • Gowda said his speech was dropped from the Pink Line event. He posted, "Reward for seeking justice for Karnataka... my speech cut."
  • He did not name anyone responsible, The News Minute reported.
  • Prime Minister Narendra Modi was to open a 7.5 km elevated Pink Line stretch on 13 November.

How each side told it

The left led with the state's grievance. Deccan Herald ran Gowda's words: "'Reward for seeking justice'." The Hindu ran the state's case: "Karnataka says loan repayments must count as State's metro contribution." The Hindu also ran Surya's figure, as "Centre bears 53% of project cost." Deccan Herald gave Surya his own headline, quoting "'Centre's share is 54%'." So the left gave both numbers, and Deccan Herald also carried Gowda's dropped speech.

What got buried

The two sides agree on almost every number. Surya's split is Rs 41,558 crore from the Centre and Rs 36,333 crore from the state, The News Minute reported in paragraph 3. Move the Rs 28,958 crore of loans from the Centre's column to the state's. The state's share becomes Rs 65,291 crore. That is Gowda's figure. The Centre's falls to Rs 12,600 crore, also his figure. So the fight comes down to one line: who gets credit for those loans. The News Minute laid this out in paragraph 4. Most headlines showed the two percentages without the bridge.

Why it matters to you

Surya said "the ordinary Kannadiga taxpayer" funds it all in the end, PTI reported. The Pink Line stretch cost about Rs 3,470 crore for 7.5 km, The News Minute reported. That is about Rs 463 crore per km. Under the Metro deal, Karnataka pays for land, resettlement and state taxes, PTI reported. Gowda said the state will ask Modi for a larger central share and faster approvals, mainly for the Sarjapur-Hebbal Red Line. That proposal is pending with the Centre, PTI reported. You can redo the sum above with the numbers each side published.

When both sides share a total, check which column moved.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.