Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

US court opens a route to serve Pannun's lawsuit on Doval, and India calls it 'fabricated'

A New York judge set a 30 November deadline for papers to go through Indian courts. Most reports led with India's reply and put the order lower.

13 outlets15 headlines3 min read
Image: Outlook

The story

A New York judge gave Gurpatwant Singh Pannun until 30 November to send court papers for NSA Ajit Doval through Indian courts. On 10 November, India's foreign ministry rejected the "fabricated and malicious attacks".

  • Pannun filed a civil suit in New York in September 2024, ANI and Outlook reported. It names the Government of India, Doval, ex-R&AW chief Samant Goel, Vikash Yadav and Nikhil Gupta.
  • The suit alleges a 2023 plot to kill Pannun in New York.
  • The US State Department signed a diplomatic note to India on 30 September and delivered it on 9 October, PTI reported. Scroll and Swarajya dated the note 20 October.
  • The note said the department had "no discretion" under US law and took no position on the case, PTI reported.
  • On 9 November, US District Judge Katherine Polk Failla allowed service through Indian courts, ANI reported. Outlook said the order used Article 19 of the Hague Service Convention, a treaty on serving papers abroad.
  • Pannun must file a service packet by 30 November, ANI and Outlook reported. The court clerk then sends it to Indian courts.
  • On 10 November, MEA spokesperson Randhir Jaiswal rejected "the frivolous lawsuits". He said such papers must go through India's Ministry of Law and Justice.
  • In the separate criminal case, Gupta pleaded guilty in February 2026, ANI reported. Outlook said that plea does not establish the civil claims. Doval and Goel have not been served yet, ANI reported.

How each side told it

The left split between the court and the government. Outlook ran: "US Judge Clears Path To Serve Summons On Doval". It named the judge, the treaty article and the 30 November deadline, the fullest legal detail we found. The Wire's headline began "After Failed Attempts". Scroll led with the US serving papers and named Jaiswal only in paragraph 14. It alone described Pannun as a US and Canadian citizen whom India designated a terrorist in 2020. Deccan Herald led with the ministry's words. So the left mostly told a court story.

What got buried

The US government's own caveat sat low. The State Department said forwarding the papers takes no position on the merits, on service or on immunity. It also said the US is not a party to the case. PTI ran this in paragraphs 10 to 13 of 13. ThePrint gave a short version in paragraph 9. The Pioneer put it in the line under its headline. A reader who stopped early could miss that Washington took no side.

Why it matters to you

The next date is 30 November. By then Pannun must file a packet with the summons, the proposed method and the relevant Indian law, ANI reported. The court clerk then sends it to Indian courts. India's position is that service must go through the Ministry of Law and Justice, Jaiswal said. So the next step runs through a ministry whose government has called the suit fabricated. No court has ruled on whether the plot claims are true. Gupta's criminal plea and this civil suit are separate cases, ANI reported. You can watch the 30 November filing to see if the case moves.

A court's first step is a long way from its last.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.