Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

Sonia Gandhi's memoir 'Belonging' is released, and the BJP calls it 'whitewashing'

The BJP attacked the book's account of the Emergency and 1984. Congress said read it first. Few reports quoted the book's own words.

20 outlets107 headlines3 min read
Image: Asianet Newsable (ANI)

The story

Sonia Gandhi's memoir went on sale on 10 November at Rs 1,299 and topped Amazon India's bestseller list, Reuters reported. The same morning, a BJP spokesperson said she should have "titled her memoir as 'Whitewashing'".

  • HarperCollins India released "Belonging: A Journey of Love" on Tuesday, 10 November, Reuters and PTI reported. Talks with Penguin Random House India had collapsed earlier, Reuters said.
  • BJP spokesperson C R Kesavan posted on X that morning. He said the book tries to "justify and normalise the notorious Emergency", PTI reported.
  • On the Emergency, the book calls it a mistake, PTI reported. Sonia Gandhi writes that keeping Sanjay Gandhi "in check" could have prevented much damage.
  • On 1984, the book calls the anti-Sikh riots a "tragic and shameful chapter", Reuters reported. Nearly 3,000 people died in those riots, Reuters said.
  • BJP leader HS Phoolka said the book dates the Army call-out to 31 October 1984. Citing the Misra Commission, he said it came on the evening of 1 November, ANI reported.
  • Congress leader Salman Khurshid told critics to read the book. "Let them play politics," he said, ANI reported.
  • On 11 November, BJP MP Sudhanshu Trivedi said the book has "many technical mistakes", PTI reported. Reuters said Sonia Gandhi had not responded herself.
  • The reports we read quote the book in short pieces. Each claim about its contents reached us secondhand.

How each side told it

The left mostly led with the book's own pages. Deccan Herald ran ten headlines, most built on quotes from the memoir, such as "Our adversary is ruthless". Another read: "1984 Anti-Sikh riots remain tragic & shameful chapter". The Telegraph put both camps in one line: "BJP sees red in Sonia's memoir". The Hindu was the left outlet that led with the BJP charge of a "clean chit" over 1984. A National Herald report on the 16 November launch put the whitewashing charge in paragraph 16 of 17. So the left mostly told the author's story.

What got buried

What the book says sat below the attack on it. PTI's story on the BJP charge gave the book's own view of the Emergency in paragraphs 3 to 5. Kesavan then filled paragraphs 6 to 11, and no Congress reply appeared. Reuters gave the Rs 1,299 price and the bestseller ranking in paragraph 14, its last. In the reports we read, only Reuters carried them. Trivedi's claim of factual errors also sat low, in paragraphs 13 and 14 of PTI's 11 November story.

Why it matters to you

Part of this fight is about dates you can check. Phoolka said the book puts the Army call-out on 31 October 1984. He said the Misra Commission, a government inquiry, puts it on the evening of 1 November. He said troops reached Delhi on the evening of 2 November, ANI reported. That is a gap of about a day, in riots where Reuters put deaths near 3,000. The book costs Rs 1,299, Reuters reported. You can hold each side to its source: a commission report on one side, a memoir on the other.

Read the page before you read the fight about it.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.