Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

Sonia Gandhi says 12 years of Modi rule damaged institutions, BJP cites the Emergency

In an interview before her memoir's release, the Congress leader said many elections were “stolen”. The BJP told her to take off her “Italian lenses”.

19 outlets51 headlines2 min read
Image: Deccan Chronicle

The story

Sonia Gandhi said “many elections have been stolen” in a Hindu interview reported on 7 November 2026. Most headlines chose a different line, about “great damage” over 12 years.

  • Sonia Gandhi spoke to The Hindu before the 10 November release of her memoir, “Belonging: A Journey of Love”, PTI reported.
  • She said “great damage” had been done over 12 years to the country, its democracy and its institutions.
  • She said the government has a “complete stranglehold” on institutions, especially the Election Commission. She also named media control, “money power” and the “exploitation of religion.”
  • On the 1975 Emergency, she said democratic rights were curtailed and habeas corpus was suspended. She also said it was imposed “constitutionally”, Republic reported.
  • BJP MP Tarun Chugh told PTI she should take off her “Italian lenses”. He cited 7.8% GDP growth. BJP spokesperson Pradeep Bhandari called her remarks a “PR exercise.”
  • HarperCollins India is publishing the 544-page book. Penguin Random House India withdrew as publisher and denied any outside pressure, National Herald reported.
  • The reports we read gave no evidence for or against her claim about stolen elections. They also did not say which period Chugh's 7.8% figure covers.

How each side told it

National Herald led with her charge. Its headline: “Stranglehold on institutions, media control”. It put her “stolen” elections line in paragraph 7 and the Penguin dispute in paragraph 11. The version we read carried no BJP reply. The Hindu ran its own interview under “Great damage done to the fabric of India by BJP”. Deccan Herald gave the rebuttal a full headline of its own: “Remove your Italian lenses”. So most of the left framed her words as a verdict on the government. One paper gave the BJP reply equal billing.

Missing context

Sonia Gandhi said the 1975 Emergency was imposed “constitutionally”. The record: President Fakhruddin Ali Ahmed proclaimed it on the night of 25 June 1975 under Article 352 of the Constitution of India, on Prime Minister Indira Gandhi's advice. The ground given was “internal disturbance”. It stayed in force until 21 March 1977. The Constitution (Forty-fourth Amendment) Act, 1978, in force from 30 April 1979, later amended Article 352 and Article 359, the emergency provisions. Whether a lawful procedure makes a decision right is a political judgment the text itself does not settle.

What got buried

Two details sat low. The first is the publisher. Penguin Random House India said it withdrew after talks stalled and denied any outside pressure. National Herald carried this in paragraph 12. The PTI copy on ThePrint mentioned an “impasse” but not the denial. Republic did not mention Penguin at all. The second is evidence. Her line that elections were “stolen” is a serious charge. None of the reports we read tested it, and the BJP replies we read did not address it. Both sides argued more about 1975 than about the claim made in 2026.

Why it matters to you

Her claim is about the vote you cast. She said the Election Commission is under the government's control. That is an allegation, and the reports we read offered no test of it. The BJP's main answer was a growth figure: 7.8% GDP growth, Chugh told PTI. A growth rate measures how fast the economy grows. It does not measure whether ballots are counted fairly. So each side answered a different question. The book comes out on 10 November. You can read her exact words there and weigh them against what the Election Commission and the courts say.

When both sides argue about the past, the present claim goes untested.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.