Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

Karnataka says petrol held up to 31.2% ethanol, oil companies dispute the tests

Karnataka's lab results showed ethanol above the 20% E20 level. IOC, BPCL and HPCL said the sampling broke set rules, and Rahul Gandhi called E20 “420”.

19 outlets30 headlines2 min read
Image: Onmanorama

The story

Karnataka said one IOCL petrol sample held 31.2% ethanol, against an E20 level of 20%. The three state oil companies said the tests broke the rules and they never got samples to retest.

  • On 6 November, Karnataka minister Rizwan Arshad released lab results for petrol from seven districts, PTI reported.
  • Shriram Research Institute in Bengaluru ran the tests. An IOCL sample showed 31.2% ethanol and an HPCL sample 30.5%, Onmanorama reported. Other samples ranged from 20.6% to 27%, and some were under the limit.
  • On 7 November, IOC, BPCL and HPCL issued a joint statement. They said the claims were “not supported by tests” done under set procedures.
  • They said their E20 petrol meets the IS 17021 standard, which allows 19% to 21% ethanol.
  • The rules require six one-litre samples, two of them for the dealer, they said. They said they got no retention samples, outlet details or lab reports.
  • Rahul Gandhi wrote on X that “E20 turned into 420”. He said 11 of 14 samples were above 20%.
  • On 9 November, Union minister Pralhad Joshi said the labs used were not on the approved Schedule 3 list, The South First reported.
  • No neutral lab has retested the disputed fuel in the reports we read.

How each side told it

The left led with Rahul Gandhi. National Herald ran: “E20 or 420?” Deccan Herald carried his line, “E20 turned into 420”, in two separate headlines. The Telegraph said he “doubles down” on the charge. Deccan Herald also gave the companies a headline, “Tests not as per norms”, and ran another for Pralhad Joshi's rebuttal. So the left framed the row as a question of trust in the Centre. The companies' method objections came second, but they were there.

What got buried

The detail placed lowest is who checks whom. The companies' own tests of 56 Karnataka samples averaged 19.30% ethanol, Joshi said. Karnataka's results came from a lab outside the approved Schedule 3 list, he added. Arshad said the state also sent 63 samples to the companies' labs and got no ethanol results back. The South First carried that in paragraph 7. So in the reports we read, each side's evidence comes from a lab the other side rejects. No headline in our list said so.

Why it matters to you

If you drive a petrol car, this is about what you pay for. The three state oil companies sold about 5,673 crore litres of petrol in the 2025-26 supply year, PTI reported. They blended 1,134 crore litres of ethanol into it. That works out to about 20%, which matches E20 on average. Karnataka's claim is about single outlets, where an average can hide a high reading. The state said high ethanol could cut mileage and harm fuel pumps and seals. It wants blend levels shown at every pump. Until a joint retest happens, both sets of numbers stay claims.

A test is only as trusted as the lab both sides accept.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.