Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

Mary Peltola unseats Sen. Dan Sullivan, giving Democrats a 56-44 Senate majority

AP called the Alaska race two weeks after Election Day. Right-leaning outlets led with a DOJ probe into a second candidate named Dan Sullivan.

26 outlets56 headlines2 min read
Image: ABC News (AP projection)

The story

Mary Peltola beat Sen. Dan Sullivan by 12,458 votes, using Fox News's totals. Two smaller candidates drew 10,865 votes combined, less than her margin.

  • The AP projected Democrat Mary Peltola the winner of Alaska's Senate race, ABC News reported. With 99% counted, she led 50% to 46%.
  • Fox News put the totals at 144,302 for Peltola and 131,844 for Sullivan. Republican Heikes had 6,105 and Dan J. Sullivan had 4,760.
  • Peltola reached 50.1%, so no ranked-choice rounds were needed, Fox News and The New Republic reported.
  • The win is Democrats' ninth Senate gain. It gives them a 56-44 majority, Fox News reported.
  • The second candidate, Dan J. Sullivan, drew 1.7%, The New Republic reported. The New York Times reported the Peltola campaign recruited him, ABC News wrote. The campaign said it had “no involvement with either Sullivan campaign.”
  • The DOJ sued to block certification. Judge Sharon Gleason dismissed the suit, the Daily Caller reported.
  • Reports differ on the probe's size. The Daily Caller said “at least three dozen subpoenas.” Fox News, citing two anonymous sources, said more than 200.
  • Trump called the race “absolutely a disgrace,” ABC News reported. No charges have been reported in the coverage we read.

How each side told it

Left-leaning outlets led with the result and the math. The New Republic ran: “The Second Dan Sullivan Made No Impact on Alaska Senate Race.” It quoted Dan J. Sullivan's Facebook post first. The DOJ lawsuit came in paragraph 9. It did not mention subpoenas or Peltola's denial. The AP call, as ABC News carried it, quoted the campaign's denial first, in paragraph 4. The probe showed up there only as a related-headline link. The Washington Post put the seat count up top: “giving Democrats a 56-44 edge in Senate.”

What got buried

The math sat in plain view and went unsaid. Fox News printed every vote total in paragraph 2. Heikes and Dan J. Sullivan together drew 10,865 votes. Peltola's lead was 12,458. If every one of those votes had gone to Sen. Sullivan, he would still trail by 1,593. The Fox story did not add them up. The AP made the point in paragraph 10. The Daily Caller, for its part, left out Peltola's denial entirely.

Why it matters to you

Alaska uses ranked-choice voting. Peltola passed 50%, so second-choice rankings never came into play, Fox News and The New Republic reported. The race turned on first choices alone. Democrats will hold 56 of 100 seats, Fox News reported. The DOJ probe is open, and its size depends on which outlet you read. One count is at least 36 subpoenas. The other is more than 200, from anonymous sources. Those counts differ by about 164. If you follow the probe, watch for court filings with names and dates.

The same vote totals told two different stories.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.