Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

House Democrats nominate Hakeem Jeffries for speaker in 251-11 vote

Jeffries is on track to become the first Black speaker when the House votes on January 3. Eleven Democrats voted no, including seven incoming progressives.

32 outlets73 headlines2 min read
Image: Reuters (via Yahoo)

The story

House Democrats backed Hakeem Jeffries for speaker 251 to 11 on Wednesday, Reuters reported. That is the most votes for a speaker candidate since 2009, NBC reported.

  • House Democrats met behind closed doors on Wednesday, November 18, and voted by private ballot.
  • Jeffries ran unopposed and won 251 to 11, Reuters, TIME and NBC reported. Breitbart, citing sources, put total ballots at 262.
  • NBC said 251 is the most for a speaker candidate since Nancy Pelosi won 255 in 2009.
  • The full House votes when the new Congress meets on January 3. A winner needs 218 votes. If he wins, Jeffries would be the first Black speaker, Reuters and TIME reported.
  • Sources differ on the majority's size. Reuters said Democrats hold “at least 257 seats,” with some races uncalled. TIME said a projected 259.
  • Seven incoming progressives released a joint statement saying “there is still work to be done.” NBC said five of the seven are DSA members. TIME said one of them missed the vote because he was sick.
  • Jeffries said, “Our job is to fight MAGA extremism, not each other,” TIME reported.
  • Democrats also chose Katherine Clark as majority leader, Ted Lieu as caucus chair and Pete Aguilar as whip, TIME reported.

How each side told it

Left-leaning outlets framed the day around the dissenters. NBC's analysis ran: “Hakeem Jeffries' progressive defectors reveal the limits of their power.” It led with the seven defectors and quoted their statement first. Jeffries was not quoted at all. The first Black speaker milestone came in paragraph 3. CNN's headline said he “overwhelmingly wins” despite “threats from ultra-progressives.” The Guardian ran “despite progressives' concerns.” All three put the progressive split in the headline, ahead of the 251 votes.

What got buried

Both sides put the revolt high and the support low. Reuters reported in paragraph 8 that Pramila Jayapal, the former Progressive Caucus chair, voted for Jeffries. In paragraph 7, it said Progressive Caucus leaders congratulated him. In the four reports we read, only Reuters carried either detail. NBC and Breitbart left both out. The dissent was real, at 11 votes. The backing from the left's own leaders was real too, and it got far less room.

Why it matters to you

Here is the margin math. On the floor, Jeffries needs 218 votes. He won 251 inside his caucus, so he could lose 33 more and still win, NBC reported. The 11 no votes are about 4% of the 262 ballots Breitbart reported. Democrats say their agenda is “affordability and accountability,” TIME and Reuters reported. The reports we read don't list which bills come first. You can track whether bills on prices reach a floor vote after January 3. That record will say more than the caucus tally.

Eleven no votes drew more headlines than 251 yes votes.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.