Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

Van Hollen says he has a path to beat Schumer for Senate Democratic leader

Schumer says he has the votes. Van Hollen says about 15 senators back him. Outlets split on what to call him and what to count.

16 outlets29 headlines2 min read
Image: ABC News

The story

Sen. Chris Van Hollen said about 15 senators back his bid to replace Chuck Schumer as Democratic leader, Politico reported. He named none of them. Schumer says he has the votes.

  • Van Hollen, a Maryland Democrat, launched his challenge on Thursday, Nov. 12. That day Schumer said, “I have the votes to continue serving as Democratic Leader.”
  • On Sunday, Nov. 15, Van Hollen went on ABC, CNN and Fox News Sunday.
  • On ABC he said, “I think there's a very open lane here.” He said Schumer's team “put out a lot of misinformation.”
  • On CNN he said, “I have a path to get there, no doubt about it.”
  • The vote is set for Dec. 1 by secret ballot, and a simple majority wins, the New York Times reported.
  • Senate Democrats have discussed moving it before Thanksgiving, Politico reported. That would mean waiving caucus rules. Van Hollen called the push “a sign of weakness.”
  • Public backers of Van Hollen include Sens. Bernie Sanders and Jeff Merkley, Politico reported. Sens. Gallego, Alsobrooks and Gillibrand back Schumer. Politico called Schumer the favorite.
  • Van Hollen is 67, and Schumer is 75, Fox News reported.
  • The reports we read don't give a full public count with names.

How each side told it

Left-leaning outlets gave Van Hollen's claims top billing. The New York Times ran: “Chris Van Hollen Says His Majority Leader Challenge to Chuck Schumer Is Gaining Support.” Its story said he has a “wide open” path, while ABC's quote was “very open lane.” ABC ran: “Van Hollen says Schumer's team trying to ‘instill fear’ to retain Senate leadership.” It quoted Van Hollen first and Schumer in paragraph 4. It gave no vote date or counts. Politico had the most process detail and called Schumer the favorite in paragraph 8.

What got buried

How the vote works got little space. In the reports we read, only the New York Times said a simple majority wins. Politico said moving the vote would mean waiving caucus rules, in paragraph 5. ABC gave no vote date at all. Van Hollen's own agenda also sat low. Fox News put his 100-day plan on Medicaid, health care credits and food aid in paragraph 18 of a Nov. 13 story.

Why it matters to you

Start with the math. The New York Times said the caucus will have at least 55 seats next year. A simple majority of 55 is 28 votes. Van Hollen claims about 15. Schumer has not released a count. Government funding runs out Dec. 11, the Times and Fox News reported. That is 10 days after the leadership vote. So whoever wins starts with a funding deadline. Van Hollen said he would give “not one penny more” for the Iran war, the Times reported. Watch for named senators, because a count with names is one you can check.

A vote count without names is a claim, whoever makes it.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.