Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

Judge pauses Trump's plan to close a public DC golf course, Trump vows appeal

Judge Ana Reyes kept East Potomac open through Nov. 28. Right-leaning headlines named who appointed her, and left-leaning ones stressed her rebuke.

12 outlets16 headlines2 min read
Image: CNN (via KEYT)

The story

A federal judge ordered the public golf course at East Potomac Park to stay open through Nov. 28. The order came Saturday night, Nov. 14, hours before a planned 15-month closure.

  • US District Judge Ana Reyes issued a temporary restraining order, a short emergency court order.
  • The plan would have closed the courses starting Sunday, Nov. 15. UPI reported that three public courses would become one 18-hole championship course.
  • Reyes found the closure likely broke federal environmental and administrative law, CNN reported. She called the safety and no-operator reasons a “pretext,” meaning a cover story.
  • The plaintiffs are the DC Preservation League and two local golfers, who sued in February. They said the plan would make the course unaffordable, AP reported.
  • Trump called it a “highly destructive and political decision.” He said Interior would “immediately appeal, on an expedited basis.”
  • A Justice Department spokesperson said it would “always vociferously defend” the administration's agenda in court, CNN reported.
  • The order allows repairs but keeps the course open during its current daily hours, Breitbart reported.
  • The reports we read don't say whether the appeal has been filed.

How each side told it

Left-leaning outlets led with the judge's rebuke and Trump's reaction. ABC News ran: “Judge admonishes Trump administration over plans for Washington, DC, golf course.” The Daily Beast ran: “Judge Smashes Trump's Golf Course Dream Into the Rough.” Raw Story opened with “Panicked Trump loses it.” CNN, in the story we read, gave the judge's legal findings in paragraphs 2 to 4. It reached Trump's appeal in paragraph 5. CNN left out the plaintiffs' cost argument, the Nov. 28 end date and who appointed the judge.

What got buried

One detail explains the judge's “pretext” finding. The administration ended the operator's contract itself, UPI reported. It then cited the lack of an operator as a reason to close. In the 4 reports we read, only UPI carried this, in paragraph 12. Reyes also quoted the government admitting this is “not the full story,” UPI reported in paragraph 13. AP and CNN left out who appointed her. Breitbart left out why she ruled.

Why it matters to you

If you golf in Washington, the course stays open during its current hours through Nov. 28. The order covers 14 days of a planned 15-month closure. It does not require anyone to actively manage the park, Breitbart reported, quoting the order. The plaintiffs argue the bigger risk is price, AP reported, though the reports we read give no fee figures. Trees are part of the fight too. CNN counted more than 400 cut, while a Breitbart caption said over 500. The full case is still open, so watch the Nov. 28 date.

Read the order before the adjectives about the order.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.