Trump says deportation push ‘might be too tough’ as aides rule out amnesty
On 60 Minutes, Trump floated an immigration deal with Democrats. His DHS chief said amnesty is off the table, and some conservatives objected.

The story
Trump told “60 Minutes” his deportation policy “might be too tough.” The interview was taped Friday, AP reported. Shortly after, he named Stephen Miller as his chief of staff.
- The CBS interview aired Sunday. AP called it his first big interview since Republicans lost control of Congress.
- “I think it might be too tough, yeah,” Trump said. He said “we would work something out” with Democrats, and gave no details.
- He said “killers” and “drug dealers” should still be deported. “Good people,” such as landscaping or hotel workers, could stay, AP reported.
- Senate Democratic leader Chuck Schumer called the Miller pick a promotion of the same approach, AP reported.
- On Monday, a White House official told Fox News: “The President never said the word amnesty.”
- DHS Secretary Markwayne Mullin said Trump told him, “Let’s start working with them.” Mullin added, “We’re never going to allow amnesty to happen,” Fox reported.
- Some conservatives objected. Steve Cortes called an amnesty deal “a bigger betrayal” than the Iran war, Fox said.
- House Democratic leader Hakeem Jeffries said Democrats are “not going to give a dime” to the “mass deportation machine.” Later, Trump said at the White House, “My policy hasn’t changed,” the Daily Beast reported.
How each side told it
The left led with the contradiction. CBS News ran: “Then he promoted Stephen Miller.” The Washington Post’s headline said Trump “now says it’s ‘very strong,’ rejects ‘amnesty.’” Vox called them “mixed messages.” A day later, the Daily Beast gave a number most others did not. In paragraph 7, it said about 90,000 people with at least a decade in the US were removed, citing the Migration Policy Institute. It did not mention Mullin or Jeffries.
What got buried
AP carried a fact that shaped the debate, in paragraph 9 of 14. Federal officers killed two US citizens, Renee Good and Alex Pretti, during protests against the crackdown. In the six reports we read, AP was the only one to name them. Neither Fox News story we read mentioned them. The Daily Beast story did not either. The AP version we read does not say when the deaths happened.
Why it matters to you
If you or someone close to you is a Dreamer, the details matter more than the mood. Mullin said any DACA legalization “that’ll be up to Congress,” AP reported. Jeffries wants a discharge petition for the American Dream and Promise Act. Fox said it needs one more Republican signature. DHS said ICE arrested 264 DACA recipients from Jan. 20 to Sept. 28, 2025. It said over 92% were charged or convicted. That leaves about 21 who were not, by DHS’s own count. Trump gave no details of a deal, AP said.
Policy lives in budgets and hires more than in interviews.
All coverage
Trump says 'too tough' deportation policies hurt him in the midterms
Day 1 for Stephen Miller as Trump's chief of staff, sources say immigration crackdown won't ease
Trump and Miller on 'collision course' as White House cleans up ‘amnesty’ mess: analyst
Trump’s mixed messages on immigration
After saying deportation policy was too tough, Trump now says it's 'very strong,' rejects 'amnesty'
Trump says his deportation policy ‘might have been too tough’ for voters in the election
What Stephen Miller Has Said About Immigration as Trump Admits Mistake
Could President Trump work with Democrats on immigration reform?
Trump says his deportation policy ‘might have been too tough’ for voters in the election
EXCLUSIVE: White House Scrambles After Trump Again Floats Amnesty Deal With Democrats
Trump admits ICE crackdown was 'too tough' and helped hand historic win to Democrats in midterms: 'That hurt me'
Immigration Hawks React After Trump Opens Up About Mass Deportation Regrets
Newt Gingrich outlines 'middle ground' on immigration and Dreamers
Jeffries vows Democrats won’t ‘give a dime’ to Trump’s deportation efforts
Trump’s Amnesty Talk Is Unlikely to Produce an Immigration Deal
Trump Faces Conservative Backlash Over Openness to Amnesty Deal
Stephen Miller has the keys. Now what about the deportations?
A Trump Amnesty Deal Would Betray Not Just His Voters But All Americans
MAGA figures outraged by Trump pitch to grant amnesty to illegal immigrants
Trump open to talking to Democrats on immigration after midterms, but Mullin stresses no amnesty
What we read to write this
- AP (via The Irish News) Trump says his deportation policy 'might have been too tough' for voters
- AP (via 1News) Trump open to talking to Dems on immigration, secretary stresses no amnesty
- Fox News White House doubles down after Trump angers base by floating illegal alien deal with Dems
- Fox News Trump tells DHS chief to work with Democrats on immigration reform, but no amnesty
- Fox News Jeffries vows Democrats won't 'give a dime' to Trump's deportation efforts
- The Daily Beast Trump Rapidly U-Turns After Shock Immigration Admission Backfires
Loading the discussion.