Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

Supreme Court lets Trump resume border wall work in Texas’s Big Bend

An unsigned order paused a lower court’s block on construction. Justice Jackson would have denied it. Environmental and church groups had sued.

26 outlets29 headlines2 min read
Image: The Post Millennial

The story

Big Bend covers about a quarter of the southern border but under 3% of apprehensions, The Post Millennial reported, citing the trial judge. On Monday, the Supreme Court let wall construction there resume.

  • On Oct. 2, US District Judge Kathleen Cardone blocked the construction, The Federalist reported.
  • SCOTUSblog said she relied on the major questions rule. That rule says Congress must speak clearly before an agency makes a huge decision.
  • The suit came from the Center for Biological Diversity, Friends of the Ruidosa Church and a river guide, AP reported. NPR described the third plaintiff as a landowner.
  • On Monday, the court paused her order in a five-page unsigned decision, NPR reported.
  • SCOTUSblog said the law lets courts hear only constitutional claims here, and this challenge was statutory. The court said border security outweighed the environmental harms.
  • Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson would have denied the request. AP and The Federalist called it a dissent. SCOTUSblog said she only noted her vote.
  • AP said Congress gave $46 billion for barriers, now going up at 12 miles a week. Plans include 30-foot steel walls, vehicle barriers and new roads.
  • Laiken Jordahl of the Center for Biological Diversity called the decision “horrific,” AP said. CBP head Rodney Scott said cartels would overrun any gap.

How each side told it

What got buried

The crossing numbers sat low or nowhere. In the six reports we read, only The Post Millennial gave the under 3% figure, in paragraph 5. NPR said the sector has the fewest encounters in Texas, in its last paragraph. AP said “low illegal immigration” with no number. The Federalist left it out. AP put one more fact in its last two paragraphs. Bulldozers already broke ground inside the national park in August.

Why it matters to you

This ruling touches public land and what judges can review. AP said Congress gave $46 billion for barriers along a 2,000-mile border. Spread evenly, that is about $23 million a mile. That is a rough average, and no report we read gave Big Bend’s own cost. SCOTUSblog said the law lets courts hear only constitutional claims against these waivers. The stay lasts until the court denies review or rules on the merits, The Federalist said. AP said no steel walls are planned inside the park, though there is no final plan. If you plan a Big Bend trip, check the park’s notices first.

The fewer facts in a headline, the louder its verbs.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.