Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

Trump calls for DOJ probe of Democrats over impeachment and investigation threats

Trump named Sen. Elissa Slotkin but cited no statute or evidence, Newsweek said. Headlines split three ways: oversight, threats or extortion.

12 outlets12 headlines2 min read
Image: CNBC

The story

Trump posted on Saturday, Nov. 7, that he was "ordering the Department of Justice" to look into Democrats. Twelve outlets in our list covered it, with at least three different words for what Democrats did.

  • On Oct. 13, Sen. Elissa Slotkin of Michigan spoke at a University of Chicago event. She talked about "signature cases" against people who "enabled" Trump, Fox News reported.
  • Democrats won both chambers of Congress on Nov. 3. On Nov. 5, Reps. Hank Johnson of Georgia and Deborah Ross of North Carolina backed impeaching Attorney General Todd Blanche, Fox reported.
  • Rep. Robert Garcia, likely the next House Oversight chair, posted "LAWYER UP," Al Jazeera reported.
  • On Saturday, Trump wrote that Democrats were threatening "a lot of people, including the Attorney General." He called it "extortion at the highest level," Newsweek and Sinclair reported. He said he was "ordering the Department of Justice to look into this criminal act." He named Slotkin.
  • Newsweek reported that Trump cited no specific federal statute and no evidence. CNBC said he did not identify the communications he meant.
  • Slotkin replied: "If you didn't break the law, then it's all good," Newsweek reported.
  • The reports we read don't say whether DOJ opened a probe on Nov. 7. Newsweek and CNBC said DOJ and the White House did not reply.

How each side told it

Left outlets chose words about oversight and jail. Politico ran: "Trump calls for DOJ investigation into Democratic calls for oversight." That headline describes what Democrats did in their own terms. Raw Story ran: "Prominent Dems threatened with 'imprisonment' as Trump orders DOJ probe in new tirade." The Daily Beast led with Trump's "EXTORTIONISTS" jail line. It said in paragraph 4 that Trump "falsely" described Slotkin's words. It put Sen. Ron Wyden's reply in paragraph 9.

What got buried

The record behind the Slotkin claim sat low. A federal grand jury had already declined to indict Slotkin and other lawmakers over a video about illegal orders. CNBC put this in its last paragraph, paragraph 10. Newsweek put it in paragraph 6. In the seven reports we read, Fox, Al Jazeera and Sinclair left it out. A second detail: Trump named none of the Democrats who backed impeachment. Only Fox named Johnson and Ross, in paragraphs 4 to 7.

Why it matters to you

Congress checking the executive branch is called oversight. This story is about whether that work gets treated as a crime. Newsweek reported that extortion requires a statute, and Trump cited none. Removing an official after impeachment needs a two-thirds Senate vote, Newsweek reported in paragraph 11. Democrats lack that, it said. Reuters reported that Democrats plan to probe major GOP donors, Fox noted in paragraph 13. If you give to campaigns, that is the part to watch. As of Nov. 7, no outlet we read reported an open DOJ case. Check whether a probe exists before you read what it means.

The verb in a headline often carries the verdict.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.