Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

Peltola campaign sues Alaska for rejected-ballot records as Senate count stays close

Peltola led Sullivan by under 700 votes with 75% counted. Trump called the race over. Most coverage of the lawsuit came from the right.

11 outlets11 headlines2 min read
Image: Democracy Docket

The story

Democrat Mary Peltola led Republican Sen. Dan Sullivan by fewer than 700 votes on Saturday, Nov. 7, with about 75% of ballots counted, the Daily Beast reported. Ranked-choice tabulation is set for Nov. 18.

  • A second man, retired teacher Daniel J. Sullivan, was also on the ballot, Fox News reported. The DOJ opened an investigation in July, Fox said. Peltola denies any role, Fox and Sinclair reported.
  • On Nov. 4, Peltola had 102,962 votes and Sullivan had 102,325, a 637-vote gap, KTUU reported.
  • On Nov. 5, Trump posted that Daniel J. Sullivan's votes should go to "the REAL Dan Sullivan," Fox reported.
  • On Nov. 6, the group Alaskans for Mary sued the Division of Elections in Anchorage Superior Court, Newsweek reported. It asked for the absentee register with "the accept or reject code" for each ballot, Breitbart reported. The campaign said it "cannot ensure that its voters' lawful votes were properly counted."
  • Alaska's Department of Law said the data is preliminary and "not yet available to affected voters," Alaska Public Media reported.
  • On Nov. 7, Trump posted: "The Alaska Race is OVER." He added the minor candidates' votes to Sullivan's total. Under ranked choice, the last-place candidate is dropped and those ballots go to each voter's next pick, Newsweek reported.

How each side told it

Few left outlets covered the lawsuit. CNN ran: "FBI probes alleged Alaska Senate spoiler scheme." That headline puts the second Sullivan at the center. Raw Story ran: "Trump melts down over red state Senate race." The Daily Beast, a left outlet we read, led with Trump declaring victory. It explained ranked-choice math in paragraph 3. It put the spoiler allegations in paragraphs 5 and 6. None of the left headlines in our list mentioned the Peltola lawsuit.

What got buried

Two facts sat low. The first is why the state said no. The data is "not yet available to affected voters," Alaska's Department of Law said. So some voters may not know yet that their ballot was rejected. Breitbart put this in its last paragraph. Newsweek put it in paragraph 12. The second is how ranked choice works. It drops the last-place candidate and moves those ballots to next choices, Newsweek said in paragraph 15. Breitbart left this out.

Why it matters to you

On Nov. 4, the top two had 205,287 votes between them, using KTUU's numbers. A 637-vote gap is about 0.3% of that. A ballot can be rejected before the voter knows, the state's statement suggests. The campaign wants the list so it can check, Alaska Public Media reported. The state says it has protected this information for years, Newsweek reported. Overseas and remote ballots count until Nov. 18, Newsweek said. At this margin, your second choice can matter as much as your first. If you vote by mail, ask your elections office how it tells you about a rejected ballot.

The closer the race, the more the rules matter.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.