Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

Vance blames Iran war for GOP losses, and Trump calls the view 'largely true'

The vice president's post on X split from his summer defense of the war. A large voter poll gives a mixed read on his claim.

20 outlets30 headlines2 min read
Image: Foreign Policy

The story

Vice President JD Vance wrote on X that "the reason we lost is the war." This summer, AP reported, he called the same Iran war "fundamentally worth it" if it transformed the Middle East.

  • Vance posted on Wednesday, Nov. 4, the day after Democrats won the House and Senate, Reuters and AP reported.
  • "The reason we lost is the war. The president himself said so last night," he wrote, per Foreign Policy.
  • AP said the post listed four factors: the war, cost of living, America's priorities and ties with Israel.
  • Trump answered on Thursday. "I think it's largely true," he said, per The Daily Beast. He still defended the war: "We stopped them from having a nuclear weapon," Reuters reported.
  • The war began in February alongside Israel. An April ceasefire stalled into a stalemate, Reuters said.
  • AP's Voter Poll of more than 100,000 voters found about 6 in 10 called the Iran action the "wrong decision." About one-third called the war "crucial" to their vote. About half said that of cost of living or corruption.
  • Fox News, citing Axios, reported that Vance privately said Netanyahu was "wrong on everything."

How each side told it

Left outlets led with the split at the top. CBS ran: "Trump says Republicans losing the midterms due to Iran war is 'largely true'." Raw Story ran: "'The president was blindsided': Vance post ignites behind-the-scenes White House dispute." The Daily Beast led with Trump's reply, called it "Jaw-Dropping" in its headline and quoted Trump first. It tied Vance to Tucker Carlson in paragraph 6. In the version we read, it gave no poll data and did not mention Vance's earlier support for the war.

What got buried

AP's last paragraph, paragraph 21, holds the contrast. This summer, on Megyn Kelly's podcast, Vance said: "If we transformed the Middle East, this is fundamentally worth it." In the five reports we read, only AP carried it. Reuters, The Daily Beast and Fox left it out. AP also wrote, in paragraphs 16 and 17, that the war "was not the leading issue for most voters." That line tests Vance's main claim, and it sat in the bottom half.

Why it matters to you

The poll lets you check Vance's claim. About 6 in 10 voters called the war the wrong decision. About 1 in 3 said it weighed most on their vote, against about 1 in 2 for cost of living or corruption. So the war was unpopular, and by AP's numbers, prices and corruption moved more votes. The war still touches your costs. Brent crude closed at $98.29 a barrel on Thursday, AP reported. Reuters said Trump is weighing a return to major combat. When a leader shifts position, check the date on the earlier quote.

The more a claim helps its speaker, the closer you check it.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.