Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

Newsom moves to commute all 548 California death sentences to life without parole

The state Supreme Court must approve 382 of the commutations. Prosecutors and some victims' families objected, and one former DA vowed a challenge.

24 outlets25 headlines2 min read
Image: Associated Press (via ABC7)

The story

Gov. Gavin Newsom said Thursday he will commute all 548 death sentences in California to life without parole. For 382 of them, the state Supreme Court gets the final say, AP reported.

  • Newsom announced the plan on Thursday, Nov. 5. The group is 529 men and 19 women, AP said.
  • He said state-sanctioned killing is "incompatible with California's values," AP reported. "These offenders will die in prison but not by our hand," he said, per CalMatters.
  • The state constitution requires Supreme Court approval for clemency for anyone with more than one felony conviction. Newsom's office said that covers 382 people, about 70%. CalMatters put it at "nearly 400."
  • Newsom paused executions in 2019. That came three years after voters rejected repeal in 2016, CalMatters reported. California last executed someone in 2006, AP said.
  • Xavier Becerra becomes governor in January and says he will extend the moratorium, AP reported.
  • Jeannine Pacioni of the state prosecutors' association called it "a profound disservice to the administration of justice." Former Sacramento DA Anne Marie Schubert pledged a court challenge, CalMatters reported.
  • The ACLU's Anthony Romero called it "an end to a racist, error-prone, and inhumane punishment," AP reported.

How each side told it

Left outlets led with scale. The New York Times ran: "Newsom Commutes the Sentences of California's 548 Death Row Inmates." Mother Jones ran: "Gavin Newsom Has Commuted the Largest Death Row in the Western Hemisphere." Both headlines read as done deals, though 382 cases still need a court's approval. CalMatters, carried by LAist, opened on history: California's first empty death row since hangings in the late 19th century. It quoted Newsom first. It placed the Polly Klaas family's split views around paragraph 31. We could not read the Times or Mother Jones in full.

What got buried

The court step got the least space. AP put it in paragraph 1 and gave the count of 382 in paragraph 6. CalMatters named it but did not lead with it. In the four reports we read, Fox and the Daily Caller left it out. Without it, the move reads as final. A second detail sat far down in CalMatters only: the commuted prisoners cannot use the state parole board's new resentencing rules.

Why it matters to you

Here is the math. 548 minus 382 leaves 166 commutations that need no court sign-off, by the governor's count. The other 382, about 70%, wait on the state Supreme Court. California has not carried out an execution since 2006, AP said, so the practical change is to the sentence on paper. Schubert said victims' families were not notified first, CalMatters reported. If you are following one case, the court's rulings will show whether that sentence changes. Those rulings are public.

A headline says done when the process still says pending.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.