Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

Talarico beats Paxton and Hinojosa ousts Abbott as Democrats win Texas

Texas elected its first Democratic senator since 1993 and its first Latina governor. Outlets blamed Trump, Musk or Paxton, depending on the side.

30 outlets48 headlines2 min read
Image: Fox News

The story

Texas elected a Democratic senator and a Democratic governor on Nov. 3. AP said no Democrat had won a Texas Senate race since 1988.

  • James Talarico, 37, a state lawmaker and former teacher, beat Attorney General Ken Paxton for the Senate seat, AP reported.
  • TheBlaze said Talarico led 59.4% to 39% when AP called the race, with votes still being counted.
  • Paxton had beaten Sen. John Cornyn in a May runoff after Trump endorsed him.
  • Gina Hinojosa, 52, an Austin state lawmaker, beat Gov. Greg Abbott, AP said. She will be the first Latina governor of Texas. Abbott called her and offered help with the handover.
  • Trump had called Abbott a "RINO" in the campaign's final months, AP reported.
  • The Senate race drew huge sums. AdImpact counted over half a billion dollars in ads, mostly for Paxton, AP said. TheBlaze cited AdImpact at over $407 million in general-election ads.
  • AP said Elon Musk gave $158 million to the Senate Leadership Fund, which passed $158 million to Paxton's largest backer. Mother Jones, citing the New York Times, put Musk's total at $212 million or more.
  • The reports we read gave no final vote totals.

How each side told it

The left led with money and Trump. Mother Jones's headline said Talarico beat Paxton "and the world's richest man." Its body said Musk spent at least $212 million. In the version we read, it barely mentioned Trump. NPR ran: "Democrat James Talarico wins Texas Senate seat." By paragraph 6, it said Trump's backing may have hurt because his popularity is underwater. NPR listed Paxton's impeachment and divorce in paragraph 10. In the 10 paragraphs we read, NPR did not mention Musk or Hinojosa.

What got buried

One campaign promise sat deep in one story. Hinojosa pledged a one-time $1,500 "Corruption Tax Refund" for each of nearly 32 million Texans, paid from the state's emergency savings fund. In the six reports we read, only AP carried it, in paragraph 16 of its governor story. AP also said in paragraph 12 that Republicans still hold the statehouse. Fox, TheBlaze, NPR and Mother Jones focused on the Senate race and did not mention the pledge.

Why it matters to you

If you live in Texas, the refund pledge is the number to watch. $1,500 times nearly 32 million residents comes to about $48 billion. A family of four would get $6,000. AP said the money would come from the emergency savings fund. AP also said Republicans still hold the statehouse. The reports we read did not say how she would pass the refund there. Hinojosa also campaigned against AI data centers, AP said. Abbott had answered those complaints with a temporary moratorium. Both promises will meet the same Republican lawmakers.

The same result can carry three different villains.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.