Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

Pediatrician Annie Andrews beats Sen. Darline Graham in South Carolina Senate race

Andrews is the first Democrat elected to the Senate from South Carolina since 1998. Graham was appointed in July after her brother Lindsey died.

24 outlets30 headlines2 min read
Image: NBC News

The story

Democrat Annie Andrews won South Carolina's Senate race 51.1% to 46.6%, NBC reported. Trump won the state by more than 17 points in 2024, NBC said.

  • Sen. Lindsey Graham died in July. NBC said he died suddenly from a heart problem.
  • Gov. McMaster appointed Graham's sister, Darline Graham, to the seat. Trump endorsed her and campaigned for her, AP said.
  • She beat Rep. Ralph Norman in a late-August runoff, Fox News reported.
  • Andrews is a pediatrician. She lost a 2022 House race to Rep. Nancy Mace and had never held office, AP said.
  • In a debate, Graham said she was "not that informed on national security," NBC reported. About two-thirds of voters in the AP Voter Poll said she lacked the right experience.
  • NBC's count at 100% of expected votes was 1,044,001 for Andrews and 952,191 for Graham.
  • AP said the last South Carolina Democrat elected to the Senate was Fritz Hollings, in 1998.
  • Graham told supporters, "This is a tough cycle." AP noted she did not use the word "concede."

How each side told it

The left put Trump at the center. CNN's headline said Trump's push for Graham "comes back to bite his party." The Daily Beast called it one of Trump's "most humiliating defeats" in its first line. NBC ran: "Democrat Annie Andrews defeats GOP Sen. Darline Graham in South Carolina, a major upset." Its body went to numbers: vote totals in paragraph 2 and the money gap in paragraph 7. NBC also reported Graham's break with Trump over Russia sanctions, in paragraph 12. That detail complicates a story told only about Trump.

What got buried

The money gap got one paragraph in one outlet. In the final two weeks, Andrews raised over $4 million and spent $4.6 million, NBC reported. Graham raised about $90,000 and spent $65,000. That is roughly 44 dollars raised by Andrews for every 1 dollar raised by Graham. NBC put this in paragraph 7. It added that the Senate Leadership Fund spent $13 million for Graham. In the six reports we read, no other outlet gave these figures.

Why it matters to you

If you live in South Carolina, your new senator gets a six-year term, Fox reported. Graham's appointed term ends at year's end. For everyone else, this seat helped decide Senate control. The Fox News Voter Poll in South Carolina found the economy was the top issue for over 4 in 10 voters. Three in four reported hardship from inflation. Andrews ran on affordability and health care, Fox said. The $13 million from an outside group did not make up for the fundraising gap. You can read candidates' own fundraising reports, which NBC used, to see who is backing them.

Voters judge the candidate, even when the name is famous.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.