Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

Judge dismisses DOJ suit over Alaska's two Dan Sullivans, and DOJ appeals

An Obama-appointed judge said the bid to set aside ballots for a second Dan Sullivan came after voting began and offered no workable way to protect ballot privacy.

35 outlets63 headlines3 min read
Image: Democracy Docket

The story

A second Dan Sullivan won about 2.5% of the vote in Alaska's August Senate primary, AP reported. On Nov. 1, a federal judge threw out the Justice Department's bid to set his ballots aside.

  • Daniel J. Sullivan, a retired teacher from Petersburg, entered the Senate race in June, AP and the Anchorage Daily News reported. He shares a name with Republican Sen. Dan Sullivan.
  • A state judge found his entry was meant to confuse voters, which he denies. Alaska courts kept him on the ballot.
  • The New York Times reported that Democrat Mary Peltola's campaign and the DSCC helped recruit him, AP and the Daily News said. Peltola, the DSCC and Daniel J. Sullivan deny it. "I am not interested in tricking voters," Peltola said, AP reported.
  • On Oct. 22, after early voting began, the Justice Department sued. It asked to separate and investigate ballots cast for Daniel J. Sullivan and to delay certification if the senator lost.
  • On Nov. 1, U.S. District Judge Sharon Gleason, an Obama appointee, dismissed the suit without a hearing. She said the request was infeasible because many people had already voted. "The United States provides no workable plan," she wrote, AP reported.
  • The department filed an appeal to the 9th Circuit the same day.
  • Over the weekend, Sen. Sullivan told CNN, "I will accept the election results," the Daily News reported. He also said Peltola was "still lying," AP reported.

How each side told it

Left outlets named Trump as the one who lost. Raw Story ran: "Trump's Alaska gambit falls apart as federal judge throws out election lawsuit." Its short story covered the ballot-privacy reasoning in paragraph 4. It did not mention the report that Democrats helped recruit the second Sullivan, the appeal or the FBI. Politico's headline said the suit sought "to stave off GOP defeat." NPR's said "Trump's attempt to block Alaska Senate results." Both titles framed the case around the outcome for Republicans and left the recruitment claim out.

What got buried

The FBI visits sat lowest. The Anchorage Daily News reported in paragraph 23 that agents went to Petersburg to question Daniel J. Sullivan's donors. It said "multiple donors" told them they were not confused. AP put the visits in its last paragraph, 29 of 29, without the donors' answers. Fox News, the Daily Wire and Raw Story left the visits out. The detail touches both sides' stories. It shows a federal probe is active. It also shows some donors said they were not misled.

Why it matters to you

If you vote in Alaska, your ballot stays private. The judge said the department gave no workable way to separate votes and keep them private. "Tens of thousands" had already voted by then, the Daily News reported. Gleason wrote that "late-breaking changes to the election rules are strongly disfavored." The appeal now goes to the 9th Circuit. Gov. Dunleavy, a Republican, ordered a state investigation and hinted he may not certify a Peltola win, the Daily News reported. His own Department of Law called the federal suit "meritless." So two fights over this race are open at once.

A headline picks the villain before the story lists the facts.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.