Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

Democrat Haley Stevens endorses Republican Mike Rogers in Michigan Senate race

Less than 48 hours before Election Day, the Democrat who lost the August primary backed the GOP nominee, and members of her staff resigned.

40 outlets99 headlines3 min read
Image: Washington Free Beacon

The story

Rep. Haley Stevens endorsed Republican Mike Rogers on Nov. 1, less than 48 hours before Election Day, NPR reported. In August she lost the Democratic Senate primary to Abdul El-Sayed and said she backed him.

  • Stevens, a Democratic House member from Michigan, narrowly lost the August primary to El-Sayed, NPR and The Daily Beast reported. She then said she supported him.
  • In late October, an outside ad tied grocery prices to US aid to Israel. NPR said it came from Cenk Uygur of The Young Turks.
  • On Friday, Oct. 30, Stevens set terms for joining a Sunday unity event with Rep. James Clyburn. She wanted El-Sayed to reject the ad and apologize for rhetoric she called offensive, NPR reported.
  • On Saturday, El-Sayed's campaign said it had no role in the ad and criticized its content, NPR reported. The Washington Free Beacon reported that he did not condemn it and disinvited her.
  • On Sunday, Stevens appeared with Rogers at Perfecting Church in Detroit. "Abdul said that I was no longer welcome in his campaign," she said, The Daily Beast reported.
  • The unity event went ahead without her. Chuck Schumer called her move a "despicable betrayal," NPR reported.
  • Her chief of staff, Justin German, and communications director Logan Basch resigned, The Daily Beast reported. In Dubuque, Iowa, Trump said Republicans "would love to have" her, the Free Beacon reported.
  • The reports we read don't agree on how many staff members left in total.

How each side told it

Left outlets led with the break inside the party. NPR ran: "Haley Stevens endorses GOP candidate in Michigan Senate race, spurning Abdul El-Sayed." It opened on the timing and quoted Stevens first. El-Sayed's reply came in paragraphs 4 and 5, and staff exits in paragraph 20. Raw Story led with Trump's praise next to the word "traitor." It carried no reply from El-Sayed. The Daily Beast called her a "Dem Loser" in its headline and opened on the staff resignations. None of the three gave polling numbers.

What got buried

The reason for the split is in dispute, and few reports said so. NPR reported in paragraph 13 that El-Sayed's campaign denied any role in the ad and criticized it. The Free Beacon reported in paragraph 13 that he did not condemn it. It said he criticized Stevens and the pro-Israel group AIPAC, citing "historic $70M in outside spending." In the reports we read, no outlet set the two accounts side by side. The unity event also went ahead with El-Sayed and Clyburn. Only NPR said so, in paragraph 16.

Why it matters to you

Republicans hold the Senate 53 to 47, CBS News reported. Democrats need a net gain of 4 seats to take it, NBC News reported. That math is why one endorsement in Michigan drew so many headlines. If you vote in Michigan, the useful facts are what each candidate said about the ad. NPR and the Free Beacon gave different versions of El-Sayed's answer. Stevens called her choice "a personal and private decision," the Free Beacon reported. You can compare both accounts before you decide which summary fits the record.

The louder the betrayal story, the less room for reasons.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.