Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

Judge dismisses Trump's Wall Street Journal Epstein letter suit with prejudice

It was Trump's second try. The judge said he again failed to show actual malice. Outlets disagreed on whether the suit sought $10 billion or $20 billion.

21 outlets23 headlines2 min read
Image: NBC News

The story

A federal judge in Miami threw out President Trump's defamation suit against The Wall Street Journal for good on Oct. 31. It was his second try, and it "cannot be refiled," AP reported.

  • Trump sued in July 2025 over a Journal story about a birthday letter to Jeffrey Epstein, CNN reported.
  • The Journal said the letter bore Trump's name and sat in an album for Epstein's 50th birthday. Trump denied writing it.
  • U.S. District Judge Darrin P. Gayles dismissed the suit in April. Trump refiled in May, AP reported.
  • On Saturday, Gayles dismissed it with prejudice. AP said that means the dismissal is permanent.
  • A public figure must show actual malice, AP reported. That means the paper knew the story was false or acted with reckless disregard for the truth.
  • Gayles wrote, "As with his first attempt, he has failed," Reason reported.
  • Outlets differed on the amount. AP and NBC said $10 billion. CNN and CBS said $20 billion.
  • Dow Jones said, "We're pleased with the court's decision," CNN reported. A Trump spokesman said he "will continue to press forward." CNN and CBS reported an appeal is likely.
  • The ruling turned on the legal standard. None of the Oct. 31 reports we read said who wrote the letter.

How each side told it

The left stressed the repeat loss. CNN ran: "Judge tosses Trump's lawsuit against Wall Street Journal again, this time for good." It called the ruling "another defeat" in a "legal campaign against the news media." CNN listed his other media suits in paragraphs 15 to 17. NBC led with the "$10 billion" figure and called the letter a "card." In paragraph 7, it said a card later released by Epstein's estate matches the Journal's description. Raw Story went further: "dealt fatal blow by judge."

What got buried

The reason the paper won sat near the bottom. Gayles noted the Journal "informed readers that President Trump decried the Letter as a fake." AP put that in paragraph 18 of 19. Reason's excerpts showed the paper also contacted Trump's team, the Justice Department and the FBI before printing. In the six reports we read, only Reason carried that list. Printing the denial was part of the paper's defense, and few headlines said so.

Why it matters to you

This case tested a rule that shapes what you read. Under New York Times Co. v. Sullivan (1964), a public figure must prove actual malice, AP reported. Gayles wrote that if a denial alone were enough, journalists "would be immediately blocked" from printing negative stories, CNN reported. Newsweek listed 8 media suits by Trump. A $15 billion suit against The New York Times is still pending, CNN reported. ABC settled earlier for $15 million toward his presidential library, Newsweek reported. A settlement and a ruling are different outcomes. When you see a lawsuit headline, check which one it was.

The size of a lawsuit says little about its strength.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.