Alaska's Republican-run state calls Justice Department ballot demand impossible
The DOJ wants ballots ranking a second Dan Sullivan set aside. Alaska says private, mixed ballots cannot be pulled apart. No one has been charged.

The story
Alaska's Republican-run state government told a federal judge on Oct. 31 that a Trump administration ballot demand is "both disturbing and impossible," AP reported. No one has been charged in the case behind it, Reuters reported.
- The New York Times reported this week that texts suggest Mary Peltola's campaign helped recruit a second Dan Sullivan, AP reported. He is a retired teacher from Petersburg. Reuters said it "could not independently confirm" the Times report.
- The Justice Department had already sued to halt certification if Peltola, the Democrat, wins, AP reported.
- On Friday, Oct. 30, prosecutor E. Bryan Wilson asked the court to "preserve and segregate all ballots ranking" Daniel J. Sullivan, AP reported.
- U.S. Attorney Michael Heyman confirmed a criminal probe that has run "several months." He named no crimes or targets.
- FBI agents visited donors in at least two Alaska towns. Petersburg donor Charles Flint said, "I don't feel like I've been misled at all," AP reported.
- Peltola said, "I am not interested in tricking voters." Sen. Dan Sullivan told Fox News she is "still lying."
- On Saturday, the state asked Judge Sharon L. Gleason to dismiss the suit. Ballots are mixed together in the box, so they cannot be pulled apart, the state said. The ballot already lists the two men differently, it added.
- No one has been charged, and it is unclear whether any law was broken, Reuters reported.
How each side told it
The left led with the federal moves and Peltola's denial. NPR ran: "Justice Department seeks to isolate Alaska ballots amid criminal probe." That story was AP copy run by NPR stations. It quoted U.S. Attorney Heyman first and used "isolate" and "confusion" for the ballot request. It put the state's objections in paragraphs 12 to 14. NBC put Peltola in its headline: "calls campaign allegations 'offensive to me.'" CBS quoted the department calling the allegations "troubling." Slate wrote about "Donald Trump's Mary Peltola Threats."
What got buried
The most buried fact is who opposed the ballot request. Alaska's state government is Republican-run. Its lawyers called the demand "both disturbing and impossible," AP reported in paragraph 4. In the six reports we read, only AP's stories carried that. Reuters, Fox News and the Daily Wire left it out. A second detail came from the FBI's own visits. Three donors told AP they had not been fooled. No other report we read had it.
Why it matters to you
The race could decide Senate control, AP and Reuters reported. Alaska uses ranked-choice voting, so a voter can rank both Sullivans, the state said. The fight is about ballot secrecy. Your ranked ballot sits mixed with everyone else's, with no name attached. The DOJ cited a "substantial risk" that the second Sullivan "will mislead voters." The state said separating those ballots cannot be done while keeping ballots private. A judge decides which concern wins. If you vote in Alaska, read the names closely. The ballot lists "Dan S. Sullivan," Republican, and "Daniel J. Sullivan Jr.," with no party.
A report is a claim until a court or a charge tests it.
All coverage
Attorneys for Alaska say 'meritless' Trump demand to set aside Senate ballots 'not even possible'
Daniel J. Sullivan left his Alaska hometown before Senate election, sources say
Comedians poke fun of Alaska’s Senate election controversy
FBI Visits Dan J. Sullivan Donor In Candidate's Home Town As Alaska Senate Inquiry Widens
Attorneys for GOP-run Alaska say 'meritless' Trump demand to set aside Senate ballots 'not even possible'
Alaska officials ask judge to deny Trump administration’s ‘impossible’ demand to set aside Senate ballots
Justice Department seeks to isolate Alaska ballots amid criminal probe over Senate candidate
The One Real Danger of Donald Trump’s Mary Peltola Threats
FBI visits Dan J. Sullivan donor in candidate's hometown as Alaska Senate inquiry widens
Attorneys for Alaska say 'meritless' Trump demand to set aside Senate ballots 'not even possible'
Alaska Calls Trump Ballot Demand Meritless, Trump’s WSJ Suit Dismissed, More
Alaska voters dismiss alleged spoiler candidate saga as 'noise'
Alaska’s decoy scandal brings back the usual suspects for shady election tactics
'Tricking voters.' Alaska's governor investigates 2 Dan Sullivans on Senate ballot
Alaska Dem Party Chair on Ballot Stacking: People Want Officials to ‘Use Every Tool’
Revealed: Alaskan voters tell the Daily Mail whether they'll vote for Democrat Mary Peltola or Republican Dan Sullivan after 'decoy' drama shakes up crucial race
Real Dan Sullivan Gets Flagged As Fake Days Before Election
Dems' dire warnings about threats to democracy face an uncomfortable reckoning after Alaska election report
Alaska Lawyers: Trump Ballot Demand 'Not Even Possible'
Alaska could take weeks to count votes - and determine who will control the US Senate
Attorneys for Alaska say 'meritless' Trump demand to set aside Senate ballots 'not even possible'
Democrats’ Alaska Senate race gimmick shows all that’s wrong with Democrats
What we read to write this
- Associated Press (via PBS NewsHour) Attorneys for Alaska say 'meritless' Trump demand to set aside Senate ballots 'not even possible'
- Associated Press (via KSAT) FBI visits Dan J. Sullivan donor in candidate's hometown as Alaska Senate inquiry widens
- NPR network (KUNC, AP copy) Justice Department seeks to isolate Alaska ballots amid criminal probe over Senate candidate
- Reuters (via Devdiscourse) Trump administration accelerates criminal probe into Alaska Senate race
- Fox News Peltola insists 'I knew nothing' about alleged 'Decoy Dan' scheme as Sullivan alleges she is 'still lying'
- The Daily Wire Real Dan Sullivan Gets Flagged As Fake Days Before Election
Loading the discussion.