Judge bars DOJ from threatening election workers with prosecution before midterms
Judge Trina Thompson issued an emergency order on Oct. 30, a day after DOJ letters warned election officials of up to a year in prison.

The story
On Oct. 29, DOJ letters warned election officials of up to a year in prison over records. The next night, a federal judge barred DOJ from threatening them with prosecution.
- In July, DOJ letters warned officials in all 50 states they could be prosecuted for knowingly letting noncitizens vote, Votebeat reported.
- On Oct. 28, Judge David Carter in California wrote: "These threats must stop."
- On Oct. 29, acting Deputy Attorney General Trent McCotter signed letters that appear to have gone to all 50 states, Votebeat reported. They cite a 1960 law that requires election records be kept for 22 months.
- The letters said failure is "punishable by up to a year in prison and a $1,000 fine," ABC reported.
- On Oct. 30, Judge Trina Thompson issued an 8-page emergency order. Unions including SEIU and AFSCME had sued, along with the NAACP and LULAC.
- The order bars DOJ and DHS from threatening officials with prosecution for processing ballots under the law, MS NOW reported. It runs through Nov. 16. She found DOJ "likely violated" the Voting Rights Act.
- DOJ said she ruled "without even waiting to hear from the United States," Newsweek reported.
- Outlets differ on the order's reach. CNN said "across the country." The New York Times headline said "in California."
How each side told it
The left led with the size of the order. CNN's headline called it a "sweeping emergency order halting DOJ pressure campaign." CNN's story called DOJ's tactics "aggressive." Its body did not quote the order on how far it reaches, despite its headline. Politico ran: "DOJ dangles legal threats over state election officials days before the midterms." MS NOW noted in paragraph 6 that the judge ruled without first hearing from DOJ, calling it an "unusual step." DOJ's main complaint rests on this point, and MS NOW was the only left outlet we read to flag it.
What got buried
Two parts of the order sat mid-story or lower. It requires the government to tell officials who got letters that the threats are blocked. It also requires DOJ to tell the court about any pending search warrants or grand jury subpoenas for election materials. MS NOW and Daily Wire both put these in paragraph 9. NBC's story left out the subpoena part. Votebeat, in paragraph 10, found the Texas letter was addressed to a secretary of state who left office in July.
Why it matters to you
Election workers count your ballot. Through Nov. 16, the order stops federal threats against them for following state and federal law. The records law is real, and the letters said breaking it carries up to one year in prison and a $1,000 fine. DOJ's letter called itself a "reminder." Former DOJ official Justin Levitt said it "certainly looks like it's meant to intimidate rather than to inform," Votebeat reported. If you work the polls, the order lists what DOJ may not demand on federal claims alone: removing voters, refusing ballots or setting ballots aside.
A reminder and a threat can use the same words.
All coverage
DOJ warns state election officials they could face jail time if they fail to preserve records
Judge imposes sweeping emergency order halting DOJ pressure campaign on election officials across the country
Justice Department can’t threaten election workers to stop processing ballots, judge rules
Judge blocks DOJ from threatening election workers with prosecution ahead of midterm
Judge Bars Trump Administration From Threatening to Prosecute Election Workers in California
DOJ dangles legal threats over state election officials days before the midterms
'Meant to intimidate': Trump's DOJ sends fresh election warnings after judge's rebuke
Federal judge bars DoJ from threatening election workers to stop processing ballots
Judge blocks DOJ from threatening election workers before midterms
Judge Orders DOJ to Not Threaten California Election Officials
Judge blocks DOJ from threatening election officials over noncitizen voting claims
Trump's DOJ issues stark ballot warning to all 50 states just days before midterms... threatening election...
DOJ Warns Election Officials to Preserve Records
What we read to write this
- NBC News Judge orders Trump administration to stop threatening election officials with criminal charges
- CNN Judge imposes sweeping emergency order halting DOJ pressure campaign on election officials across the country
- MS NOW Judge blocks DOJ from threatening election workers with prosecution ahead of midterm
- ABC News DOJ warns state election officials they could face jail time if they fail to preserve records
- Votebeat DOJ again warns election officials of potential criminal prosecution, days before midterm elections
- The Daily Wire Biden-Appointed Judge Orders Trump Admin To Stop Threats Days Before Midterms
- Newsweek Trump DOJ blocked nationwide from threatening election officials
Loading the discussion.