Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

DHS chief calls Omar case sent to DOJ 'large' as no charges are filed

Right-leaning outlets ran the Ilhan Omar marriage probe widely on Oct. 30. No left-leaning outlet in our list ran a headline on it that day.

9 outlets11 headlines2 min read Blindspot for the left
Image: The Federalist

The story

Nine right-leaning outlets ran headlines on the Ilhan Omar marriage probe on Oct. 30. No left-leaning outlet in our list did. No charge had been filed.

  • Federal agents searched Rep. Ilhan Omar's Washington home on Oct. 12, Newsweek reported. They took her phone, CBS reported.
  • Attorney General Todd Blanche attested the timing was not meant to affect any election, Newsweek and Breitbart reported.
  • The probe partly examines whether Omar's 2009 marriage to Ahmed Nur Said Elmi was a sham, The New York Times reported on Oct. 29.
  • The Times said the FBI and DHS found "some evidence" of fraud in 2016. Prosecutors did not charge because a five-year limit had passed.
  • On Oct. 30, Breitbart carried DHS Secretary Markwayne Mullin's words: "This is a large case that we have presented to the DOJ."
  • Omar's spokesperson called the claim a "baseless, disgusting conspiracy theory," the Times reported.
  • The Times also said it is unclear what evidence shows the man she married was her brother.
  • Every outlet we read said no charge against Omar had been filed.

How each side told it

Left-leaning outlets ran no headline on the probe on Oct. 30, in our list of 48 outlets. The New York Times had reported on it a day earlier. Its Oct. 29 story said the probe "partly" examines a possible sham marriage in 2009. It quoted Omar's spokesperson in full. The Times put the time limit mid-piece. It also said a marriage-fraud charge would not threaten her citizenship. MS NOW had aired Omar's own answer on Oct. 21. Readers who checked only on Oct. 30 saw nothing on this from the left.

No left-leaning outlet we read ran this story.

What got buried

Omar's denials and the legal limits sat low. On MS NOW, Omar said "Not to my knowledge" when asked if Elmi is related to her. Her spokesperson called the answer sarcastic, Newsweek reported. Most right-leaning coverage we read left out that explanation. The Times reported that the five-year limit may block any marriage-fraud charge. CBS noted in paragraph 8 that a racketeering case also has a five-year limit. Breitbart put Blanche's election-timing attestation in its last paragraph, 14.

Why it matters to you

Omar is on the Nov. 3 ballot, seeking a fifth term, the Times reported. The home search came 22 days before Election Day. A search warrant does not establish wrongdoing, Newsweek noted. More than a dozen grand jury subpoenas went out in mid-October, Fox News and Breitbart reported. Mullin said, "We're not weaponizing." Omar called the probe "an attempt to target political enemies," CBS reported. More than 170 House Democrats urged DOJ to drop it, Breitbart reported. Daily Wire put the count at more than 100. If you read one side, read the denial and the time limit too.

Choosing what to leave out is also a framing choice.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.