Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

Supreme Court lets New Hampshire bar student IDs at the polls for Nov. 3

An unsigned order paused a lower-court ruling, citing the rule against late election changes. Justice Jackson dissented. No report we read said how many voters it affects.

10 outlets10 headlines3 min read
Image: The National News Desk (KATV)

The story

The Supreme Court on Oct. 22 let New Hampshire refuse student IDs at the polls, 12 days before the Nov. 3 election. Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson was the only noted dissent.

  • Gov. Kelly Ayotte signed House Bill 323 in April 2026, SCOTUSblog reported. It removed high school and college IDs from the list accepted to get a ballot.
  • That same month, Secretary of State David Scanlan told officials student IDs could not be used at all. That covered a backup path for voters without photo ID, SCOTUSblog said.
  • On Oct. 2, US District Judge Joseph Laplante left the law in place. He blocked Scanlan's directive, saying it went beyond the law.
  • The 1st Circuit refused to pause his ruling. The Federalist reported the vote was 2-1, on Oct. 14.
  • The Supreme Court's unsigned order paused Laplante's ruling. It cited the Purcell principle, which tells courts to avoid changing election rules close to an election.
  • The order said "the District Court did not point to anything" to justify a change. Jackson wrote that the lower court "issued a targeted order."
  • The pause lasts while appeals continue, SCOTUSblog reported.
  • Sponsor Rep. Donald McFarlane called it "a victory for common sense," AP reported. The groups that sued say the law was "intended to discriminate against young voters."

How each side told it

Left-leaning headlines stressed how far the ban reaches. The New York Times ran: "Supreme Court Allows Blanket Ban on Student IDs at Polls in New Hampshire." Raw Story's headline put "misleading" in quotes about a GOP election official's information. The left-leaning report we read in full, from Common Dreams, quoted Jackson's dissent first, in paragraph 2. It then quoted a group calling to expand the Court. Sen. Jeanne Shaheen came in paragraphs 6 and 7. She said the Court "made it harder for our Granite State students to vote." It did not name the bill, Judge Laplante or the Purcell reasoning.

What got buried

The practical details sat low or out on both sides. None of the reports we read on the order listed which IDs still work. Valley News did, one day earlier. Its list covers a driver's license from any state, a US passport, a US Armed Services ID or other government ID. That includes a $20 state non-driver ID. No report we read said how many voters the ban affects. NHPR said local officials report that students rarely show up with only a student ID.

Why it matters to you

If you are a college student voting in New Hampshire, your school ID will not get you a ballot on Nov. 3. A license from your home state still works, Valley News reported. The state's non-driver ID costs $20. The groups that sued said DMV offices need appointments and are often 30 or more minutes from campus. So plan for the trip as well as the fee. Reports also disagree on registration. NHPR said the law removed school IDs for registering. Valley News said it did not. Ask your local election office before Election Day.

The detail that helps you most is often printed last.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.