Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

Judge orders Trump to sit for BBC deposition by Dec. 11 or risk losing $10 billion suit

Trump cancelled an Oct. 16 deposition. A Miami magistrate set a deadline, and outlets split on whether to lead with the risk of dismissal.

14 outlets14 headlines3 min read
Image: Fox News

The story

A federal magistrate judge in Miami ordered President Trump to sit for questioning by BBC lawyers by Dec. 11, AP reported. If he does not, his $10 billion lawsuit could be dismissed.

  • Trump sued the BBC in December over an edited clip of his Jan. 6, 2021 speech. He seeks $5 billion for defamation and $5 billion under a Florida trade law, Fox News reported.
  • The BBC admits it spliced the clip and has apologized, AP reported. Its top executives resigned. It denies defamation and says the program never aired in the US, NBC reported.
  • Trump cancelled an agreed Oct. 16 deposition, citing a "matter of national importance," AP reported. BBC lawyer Charles Tobin said Trump was campaigning in Georgia that day.
  • On Oct. 22, Magistrate Judge Enjoliqué Lett set the Dec. 11 deadline. Discovery ends Dec. 18. Missing the deadline could bring sanctions up to dismissal, AP reported.
  • Trump's lawyers had offered a date in January, NBC and CBS reported. Lett allowed video for the lawyers' use only, AP said.
  • The BBC may also get Mar-a-Lago membership records from 2020 to 2026, AP reported. The BBC says they bear on his claimed damages.
  • A Trump spokesperson said the "powerhouse lawsuit is holding the BBC accountable," NBC reported.
  • One limit: reports differ on who the presiding judge is. NBC named Jeffrey Kuntz. We could not confirm this in another report.

How each side told it

Left-leaning outlets put the dismissal risk first. NBC News ran: "Judge orders Trump to sit for deposition in his $10 billion lawsuit." Its first sentence said he could lose the case. NBC quoted BBC lawyer Charles Tobin first, in paragraph 3, including his "fake news" remark. A Trump spokesperson came in paragraph 7. The New Republic ran: "Trump Ordered to Sit for Deposition as His BBC Lawsuit Blows Up." CBS News alone reported that Trump went to a Republican event at Mar-a-Lago after the Georgia stop. NBC did not describe how the clip was spliced.

What got buried

The fight over where the case belongs sat low. The BBC says it never aired the program in the US, NBC reported in paragraph 9. That claim is the basis of its motion to throw the case out. Trump's amended complaint counts 34 plays in Florida by 10 VPN users, TheWrap reported in August. The BBC says those plays were unauthorized. In the reports we read on the Oct. 22 order, only NBC raised the never-aired defense. The AP and Fox News stories did not.

Why it matters to you

The dates are what to watch. Trump must sit by Dec. 11, and discovery closes Dec. 18, AP reported. The BBC also subpoenaed former special counsel Jack Smith. The Justice Department must answer by Nov. 2 on whether he can testify. The money on paper is large. A BBC lawyer said "this 12-second edit that aired in England costs him $10 billion." By that framing, each second of footage carries about $833 million. If you follow defamation law, this case tests whether a US court can rule on a foreign broadcaster's show.

Where a deadline sits in the story shapes what you take from it.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.