Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

EU proposes €45 billion Ukraine loan for 2027, repayable after Russian reparations

The loan covers two-thirds of Ukraine's €70 billion gap next year, and the EU budget is expected to pay the interest, Reuters reported.

9 outlets16 headlines2 min read Blindspot for the right
Image: The Guardian (via Irish Examiner)

The story

The European Commission proposed a €45 billion loan for Ukraine on Wednesday, Reuters reported. Ukraine repays only after Russia pays reparations. Of the 9 outlets in our list on it, none leans right.

  • EU leaders asked the Commission in October to plan for Ukraine's €70 billion funding gap in 2027.
  • On 18 November, Ursula von der Leyen proposed a €45 billion loan, about $49 billion, AP reported. It covers two-thirds of that gap.
  • Up to €25 billion would go to military needs, such as drones and air defence, and up to €20 billion to budget support, Euronews reported.
  • The EU would borrow the money jointly on markets. Ukraine repays only after Russia pays reparations, Reuters reported.
  • Two laws are needed, and the budget change needs all 27 governments to agree, a Reuters explainer said.
  • Reuters and AP named three countries that opted out last time: Hungary, Czechia and Slovakia. The Guardian and Euronews added Bulgaria.
  • "I'm very confident we will agree by 27," von der Leyen said, Euronews reported. Leaders debate the plan at a summit next week.

How each side told it

Left-leaning outlets led with Ukraine's need. The Guardian ran: "EU proposes €45bn loan for Ukraine to avert cash crisis and boost defences." It quoted von der Leyen first, calling the loan a way to give Ukraine "a strong hand at the negotiating table." It named four objecting countries in paragraph 10. It did not mention the interest cost. The Independent asked a question: "Ukraine warns of a €70 billion funding gap. Will the EU step in?" We could not read that piece. The Washington Post ran AP's headline: "EU proposes fresh $49 billion loan for Ukraine as war costs mount."

What got buried

The interest bill sat low. The EU budget is expected to pay 100% of the interest, about €2 billion to €2.5 billion a year from 2028. A Reuters explainer said so in paragraph 13 of 17. Reuters' main story, AP and the Guardian did not mention it. Euronews put it up top only in a follow-up on 19 November. AP called the earlier €90 billion loan "interest-free" in paragraph 2. That is true for Ukraine, but Euronews said EU taxpayers pay about €3.5 billion a year on it.

Why it matters to you

If you live in the EU, part of your taxes may cover this. Euronews put the yearly interest on both Ukraine loans at about €6 billion. One plan pays it from the Ukraine envelope in the 2028 to 2034 EU budget, Euronews reported. That would cut the envelope by €42 billion, from €100 billion. A senior EU official said "there can always be a political decision to waive the debt." No source we read gave a cost per person or per country. The summit next week is where governments say yes or no.

The quieter the cost, the harder it is to find.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.