Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

UK sanctions eight Israeli settlement builders, and Israel vows countermeasures

Foreign Secretary Ed Miliband froze the assets of eight firms and a group that blocked Gaza aid. The Guardian said the firms' UK exposure is untested.

13 outlets13 headlines2 min read
Image: The Guardian (via AOL)

The story

Britain sanctioned eight Israeli firms that plan and build West Bank settlements on Tuesday, France 24 reported. The Guardian said these are Britain's first such sanctions on Israeli companies.

  • Foreign Secretary Ed Miliband announced the move on 17 November.
  • The sanctions freeze assets and disqualify company directors, France 24 and Reuters reported.
  • Reuters named three firms: Har Hevron Development Company, Hemdat Shomron and S.A.G. (Velvel) Construction and Development. France 24 named a fourth, Harey Zahav.
  • Britain also sanctioned Tzav 9, a group that blocked Gaza aid.
  • The move came just before final bids close on the E1 building tender, Reuters said. France 24 said that tender covers more than 1,200 homes.
  • "Do not bid, do not build, and do not profit," Miliband said.
  • Gideon Sa'ar, Israel's caretaker foreign minister, said Israel "will take countermeasures," France 24 reported. Settler leader Israel Ganz called it a "declaration of economic war on Israel."
  • Australia separately sanctioned three settlers and four groups the same day, ABC News reported.
  • The reports we read named only four of the eight firms.

How each side told it

Left-leaning outlets led with the sanctions and their purpose. The Guardian ran: "Ed Miliband announces first sanctions on Israeli firms working in West Bank." It stressed "first" and reported Miliband's hope to work with a new Israeli government. It quoted Gadi Eisenkot in paragraph 4. The Guardian version we read had no Israeli government reaction. Al Jazeera took the British reason into its headline: "UK sanctions Israeli settlement firms to protect two-state solution." CBC put a legal judgment in its headline, calling the settlements "illegal."

What got buried

The sanctions may bite less than the headlines suggest. The Guardian said in paragraph 5 that whether the eight firms rely on British money at all "is untested." In paragraph 6 it said Britain's September ban on settlement goods is still not in force. In the five reports we read on the UK move, only the Guardian raised either point. The other reports gave the asset freeze without asking what it can reach.

Why it matters to you

Count the targets. Britain hit eight firms plus one group, for nine in total. Australia hit three people and four groups, for seven. Australia's rules can fine or jail anyone who deals with them, ABC reported. If you work in UK finance or property, check any links to these names. The E1 tender covers more than 1,200 homes, France 24 said. ABC News said a final decision on E1 is due on 19 November. You can watch that date to see if the sanctions changed anything.

A sanction is as strong as the money it can reach.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.