Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

China cuts tariffs on C$400 million of Canadian pork and seafood after Carney-Xi talks

Canada extended refunds of its steel and aluminum surtax in return. The deal adds no new electric vehicle terms.

10 outlets25 headlines2 min read
Image: National Post (via Yahoo News Canada)

The story

China will drop tariffs of up to 25% on about C$400 million of Canadian pork and seafood, CBC reported on Tuesday. In return, Canada widened a break on its own 25% steel surtax.

  • Prime Minister Mark Carney met Xi Jinping on 17 November, before the APEC summit in Shenzhen, AP reported.
  • The relief covers $116 million of frozen pork and $285 million of fish and seafood, Carney's office said.
  • China also extended a pause on tariffs for canola meal, peas, lobster and crab, CBC reported.
  • In return, Canada extended refunds of its 25% surtax on some Chinese steel and aluminum for two years. It added 32 more tariff items, Carney's office said.
  • "This is the right choice," Xi said, according to AP.
  • The deal adds no new electric vehicle terms. Canada's January deal lets in 49,000 Chinese EVs a year at a 6.1% tariff, AP said.
  • Chinese state media reported a "positive consensus" on Chinese bank branches in Canada, the National Post reported. Canadian statements did not mention it.
  • The government readout said nothing on human rights or detainees, CBC reported. We found no official US response in the reports we read.

How each side told it

The left-leaning CBC was the most doubtful outlet we read. It ran: "Gains in Canada-China trade deal don't go both ways, says Kovrig." Its main story quoted Michael Kovrig, once detained in China, before any official. In paragraph 12 it said the readout skipped human rights and detainees. It gave Peter Navarro's line "China is going to eat Canada alive" in paragraph 17. The New York Times kept it plain: "Carney and Xi Announce Canada-China Trade Pact." Al Jazeera led with "tariff relief" in its headline.

What got buried

Chinese car makers are lining up, while their factories are not. CBC reported in paragraphs 32 to 35 that Geely now has Transport Canada approval to import cars, after BYD. In the same passage it said none of the expected Chinese EV factory investment has happened. AP and the National Post left both points out of the versions we read. Carney's office named no car maker. In the five reports we read, only CBC carried it.

Why it matters to you

Add up the relief: $116 million of pork plus $285 million of seafood is about $401 million. If you work in fishing or hog farming, tariffs of up to 25% come off that trade, CBC reported. Canada's exports to China rose from $3.1 billion in January to $4.4 billion in September, the National Post reported. If you shop for a car in Canada, nothing changes yet. EV imports remain well below the 49,000 quota, CBC said. The cost side is steel. More Chinese steel and aluminum gets the 25% surtax refunded.

A trade deal is two lists, and headlines print one.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.