Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

Burnham says Brexit 'has not worked' days before UK-EU reset summit

The UK prime minister set three tests for any new EU deal, and the right led with a 'Farage penalty' clause no report we read put a price on.

15 outlets55 headlines3 min read
Image: NBC News (AP)

The story

Andy Burnham told a City of London audience on Nov 16 that Britain has "lost more than we gained" from Brexit. He goes to an EU summit in Brussels on Friday, Nov 20.

  • Burnham spoke at the Lord Mayor's Banquet on Monday evening. He said, "The Brexit we were given has not worked," AP and the BBC reported.
  • He said estimates of the economic damage range from 4% to 8% of GDP, AP reported.
  • He set three tests for any deal, the BBC reported. It must fit Labour's 2024 manifesto, with no return to the single market, customs union or free movement. It must move closer to what voters backed in 2016. It must bring real gains to daily life.
  • Friday's summit covers food and drink checks, emissions trading and a youth scheme, AP and the BBC reported. The Guardian said the summit deals could raise GDP by 0.4%, about £17bn.
  • Boris Johnson said "people will wake up to what is going on," AP reported. The Conservatives said Burnham was "dragging us into the European Union via the back door," the BBC reported.
  • The Times and the Express reported a clause in the food deal. Either side that pulls out would pay compensation, including the cost of bringing back food checks. No report we read gave an amount.

How each side told it

The left led with Burnham's own words. The Guardian ran: "Andy Burnham to say Brexit 'has not worked' and he will sign new deal with EU." Its follow-up opened on Britain's lost "global standing." It quoted Burnham first and did not quote Badenoch, Johnson or Farage in the version we read. The Independent picked his security line: "Isolation caused by Brexit is what our enemies want." The Guardian put an EU lawmaker's caveat in paragraphs 10 to 12. Sandro Gozi said the UK may get only a "consultative role." The left told the story from the podium.

Missing context

Burnham's 4% to 8% range leans on official forecasts. The Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR), the UK's official fiscal watchdog, assumes Brexit leaves the UK's long-run potential productivity 4% lower than if it had stayed in the EU. It also assumes imports and exports both end up about 15% lower. In March 2024 the OBR said its assumptions "appear to be broadly on track" (OBR, Brexit analysis, as quoted by Bloomberg). The 8% top of Burnham's range is not an OBR figure, and we did not find its source.

What got buried

The size of the gain got the least space. The Guardian put the summit's possible boost at 0.4% of GDP, about £17bn, in paragraph 6. In the reports we read, only the Guardian and Ara, a Catalan paper, gave any gain figure. AP, the BBC, HuffPost and the Express gave none. AP did carry the cost side, Burnham's 4% to 8% range, in paragraph 9. AP attributed it to "he said," with no study named. Readers got a damage range without its source and almost never got the gain.

Why it matters to you

Two numbers frame what this means for you. The Guardian's estimate puts the summit gain at about £17bn, or 0.4% of GDP. Burnham's damage range is 4% to 8% of GDP. The math: 0.4 is one tenth of 4. So even on the lowest damage figure, Friday's deals would win back about a tenth of it. The food and drink deal sits closest to your shopping. Leaving it would mean bringing back food checks at the Channel and Irish Sea, the Express reported. No report we read estimated a change in food prices. Look for that number after Friday.

A number without a source is an opinion with decimals.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.