Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

Trump, Xi and Putin plan first three-way meeting at APEC in Shenzhen

The White House and the Kremlin confirmed the talks. A senior US official said no nuclear agreement is expected.

9 outlets11 headlines2 min read
Image: Associated Press (via Boston Globe)

The story

The leaders of the world's biggest nuclear powers plan to sit at one table in Shenzhen on Thursday. A senior US official told Reuters, "we do not expect to get to any kind of agreement."

  • The White House confirmed on Friday, November 13, that Donald Trump, Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin plan to meet, AP reported.
  • The meeting is set for Thursday on the sidelines of the APEC forum in Shenzhen, China. APEC brings together 21 economies, AP said.
  • Trump wants to discuss the Iran war and a three-way deal on nuclear arsenals, AP reported. A senior US official said Trump would steer away from Ukraine.
  • The New START treaty expired in February. That left the two largest arsenals uncapped for the first time in over half a century, AP said.
  • The sources give different counts for China's warheads. AP said over 600. Reuters said around 500. Both said the US and Russia each hold more than 5,000.
  • Two people familiar with the planning told Reuters that no agenda or format had been settled. A Chinese embassy spokesperson said, "We have nothing to share at the moment."
  • Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov dismissed comparisons to the 1945 Yalta conference, AP reported. Analysts told AP the meeting will be "heavier in symbolism than substance."

How each side told it

The left framed it as a big moment with open questions. Al Jazeera ran an explainer: "Trump-Xi-Putin trilateral meeting at APEC: What to expect." The Independent called it a "historic meeting" and named the White House as its source. Neither headline named Iran or nuclear arms, the two topics AP said Trump wants to raise. The Independent ran a separate opinion headline the same day calling Trump's diesel deal with Putin "a shambles." So its news headline stayed on the event, and its views went elsewhere.

Missing context

The Yalta Conference ran from February 4 to 11, 1945, in Crimea, says the US State Department's Office of the Historian. Franklin D. Roosevelt, Winston Churchill and Joseph Stalin attended. The Soviets were granted "a sphere of influence in Manchuria" for entering the war against Japan. The leaders also agreed on postwar rule of Germany and a veto for five permanent UN Security Council members. Critics use the name today for great powers dividing influence over smaller states, Reuters reported.

What got buried

China's reluctance sat low in most coverage. Reuters quoted CSIS analyst Edgard Kagan in paragraph 5: "the Chinese do not want arms control discussions." AP said in paragraph 10 that officials admit China finds the topic hard to engage on. AP added that China has shown little interest in a nuclear pact. Of the 11 headlines we grouped, only Reuters put Xi's doubts up top: "Trump and Putin push for a meeting that Xi is wary of hosting."

Why it matters to you

New START capped the US and Russian arsenals until February, AP said. Each now holds more than 5,000 warheads, both wires reported. China holds 500 to 600, depending on the source. That is about one tenth to one eighth of either. This gap is why China has shown little interest in a three-way pact, AP reported. A senior US official called the meeting the "beginning of hopefully a conversation" on disarmament. When results come out, you can measure them against that low bar.

The bigger the photo, the smaller the expected agreement.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.