Italy fines Meta €805 million over Facebook access to Android photos
Italy's privacy regulator said the Facebook app used gallery photos without specific consent and gave Meta 60 days to change the feature.

The story
Italy fined Meta €805 million, about $887 million, on Saturday. The regulator said Facebook's Android app used gallery photos without specific consent, and gave Meta 60 days to fix it.
- The Italian Data Protection Authority, called the Garante, announced the fine on November 14, AP reported.
- It said the Facebook app on Android "accessed photos, videos and associated metadata" without specific consent, Al Jazeera reported.
- The feature is called "Get suggestions from gallery when browsing Facebook." It suggests phone photos and videos for posting. Investigators found it was on by default, AP said.
- Facebook asked for gallery access through one permission that covered several app functions, AP reported. The regulator said this broke a European privacy directive written into Italian law.
- Meta has 60 days to turn the feature off and ask for separate consent, AP said.
- The sources describe the 20 million figure differently. AP said Italy has about 20 million Android users. Al Jazeera said up to 20 million users could have been affected.
- The fine is the Garante's largest ever, Al Jazeera said. It equals about 0.47% of Meta's global turnover. The regulator cited Meta's "lack of cooperation" and a 2019 fine.
- Meta made no immediate comment, AP said. It can appeal.
How each side told it
The left led with the dollar figure. The Washington Post ran the AP headline: "Meta fined $887 million in Italy over Android gallery photos and videos on Facebook." Al Jazeera ran: "Italy fines Meta $880m over photo privacy." Its own first paragraph says $887 million, a $7 million gap with its headline. Al Jazeera gave the 20 million figure in its photo caption and paragraph 7. It put the question of AI training in paragraph 10. It said the case did not examine it.
What got buried
Meta's challenge to Italy's authority sat low. AP reported in paragraph 6 that the fine went to Meta Platforms Ireland Limited, which challenged Italy's jurisdiction. Al Jazeera's report did not mention it. None of the 9 headlines we grouped did either. The default setting got little space too. AP put it in paragraph 3, and Al Jazeera in paragraph 5. That detail tells users the option was on unless they turned it off.
Why it matters to you
If you use Facebook on Android, you can check for the option named "Get suggestions from gallery when browsing Facebook." The regulator found it on by default. The fine equals about 0.47% of Meta's global turnover, the reports said. That math puts the turnover used near €171 billion, since €805 million divided by 0.0047 is about €171 billion. For Meta the share is small. For Italy's regulator it is a record. The reports we read cover Italy only.
The default setting decides more than the consent screen does.
All coverage
Italy fines Meta $880m over photo privacy
Meta fined $887 million in Italy over Android gallery photos and videos on Facebook
Meta fined $887 million in Italy over Android gallery photos and videos on Facebook
Italy Fines Meta €805 Million Over Access to Users’ Photos
Italy fines Meta $887 million over Android users' data access
Italy slaps Meta with €805mn fine over access to Android photos
Italy fines Meta $880 mn over photo privacy: authority
Italy hits Meta with €805M fine over privacy law violation
Italy fines Meta $887 million over Android users' data access
Loading the discussion.