Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

New Stay Out campaign says rejoining the EU would cost Britain £750m a week

Brexit veterans launched a campaign as Prime Minister Andy Burnham seeks a closer EU deal. Almost all coverage came from right-leaning outlets.

7 outlets13 headlines2 min read Blindspot for the left
Image: LBC

The story

A new campaign called Stay Out says rejoining the EU would cost Britain £750m a week. That is a gross figure, before any money flows back to the UK.

  • On November 12, Prime Minister Andy Burnham spoke at a European summit in Ireland, LBC reported.
  • He said a new EU deal "could be a win-win for Britain and Europe." He also said "no one's talking about rejoin."
  • The planned deals cover food and farming rules, emissions trading and youth travel, LBC reported. Burnham said they could add 0.4% to GDP.
  • A new group, Stay Out, then launched. Oliver Lewis, Vote Leave's former head of research, chairs it, the Spectator reported.
  • Stay Out applied EU budget forecasts for 2028 onward to UK data. It got gross payments of about £39bn to £40bn a year.
  • "On the Commission's own numbers it would cost us £750 million a week," Lewis said. The group says there would be no rebate.
  • Michael Gove backs the campaign, The Times reported. A UK-EU summit is due in Brussels next week.
  • No independent check of the £750m figure appeared in the reports we read. No government reply to it did either.

How each side told it

The left barely covered the campaign. On our list, only The Independent ran a related headline: "Andy Burnham hits back at David Cameron over criticism of his EU plans." It framed the story around Burnham answering a critic. Its headline did not name Stay Out or the £750m figure. We could not load the Independent text, so we cannot say if the figure appears lower down. No other left-leaning outlet on our list ran a headline on the campaign. The BBC, a center outlet, ran it plainly: "New campaign against EU membership launches ahead of UK-EU summit."

What got buried

Two details sat low or nowhere. First, the figure is gross. In the reports we read, none gave a net figure after money returns to the UK. Second, Burnham said "no one's talking about rejoin," LBC reported. Sources disagree on this. LondonLovesBusiness said Burnham called rejoining an option. In paragraph 11 it also carried a Lords committee finding. The food deal could mean adopting at least 780 EU laws a year. That cost of the actual plan got far less space than £750m.

Why it matters to you

Here is the math. £39bn a year divided by 52 weeks is £750m a week. In 2016, the UK's gross payment was £19.1bn a year, Stay Out says. So the campaign's figure is about double. If the EU's six proposed new levies fail, Stay Out puts the bill at £41.8bn a year, or £803m a week. These are gross numbers from a campaign, with no outside check in the reports we read. Burnham's own 0.4% GDP gain is also unchecked. Ask any campaign for its net figure before you share it.

A cost figure without a net figure is half an answer.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.