Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

Israeli strike on Gaza's Nasser Hospital kills 6, including a surgeon

Israel said it targeted a Hamas commander inside. AP reported he was not among the dead. Hamas denied any military use of the hospital.

22 outlets32 headlines3 min read
Image: Al Jazeera

The story

Two missiles hit the surgery building of Gaza's Nasser Hospital early Thursday and killed 6 people, the Gaza Health Ministry said. The commander Israel said it was targeting was not among the dead, AP reported.

  • The strike came shortly after midnight on Thursday, November 12, said British volunteer surgeon Goher Rahbour. He called it "very loud, very quick," AFP reported.
  • Medics and witnesses said 2 missiles hit the roof of a five-storey building with surgery wards, Reuters reported.
  • The Health Ministry said 6 people died. They include surgeon Dr. Rizk Abu Shaira and at least 2 patients, one a 13-year-old boy, AP reported.
  • Counts of the wounded differ. Reuters said 20. AP said at least 28, citing the ministry.
  • The Israeli military said it targeted Muhammad Abu Ismail, "the commander of Hamas' Khan Younis Brigade." It accused Hamas of "turning the Nasser Hospital compound into a headquarters," Reuters reported.
  • Israel said it gave warnings "on several occasions, including recently." The hospital's general director, Dr. Ahmed al-Farra, said there was no warning, AP reported. Hamas denied any military use of the hospital, AFP reported.
  • Israeli fire killed 11 people across Gaza that day, including the 6, AFP reported. Health officials told AFP it was the deadliest single strike since Israel's election last month.
  • The Israeli military released graphics of the building but "no further evidence," ABC News Australia reported.

How each side told it

The left led with the dead doctor. Al Jazeera ran: "'Horrific crime': Gaza doctor killed as Israel expands war on healthcare." It opened with a quote and gave no Israeli reason in the headline. CNN ran: "Israeli strike on Gaza hospital kills at least 6, including doctor and child." ABC News (Australia) ran: "IDF claims responsiblity for deadly strike on Gaza hospital," typo included. ABC's story did carry Israel's command-centre claim near the top. It noted the missing evidence in paragraph 15. Al Jazeera said in paragraph 4 that most of the dead and wounded were patients.

Missing context

The rules on hospitals in war are set out in Article 19 of the Fourth Geneva Convention of 1949. It says a civilian hospital keeps its protection unless it is used, "outside their humanitarian duties," for "acts harmful to the enemy." Even then, "Protection may, however, cease only after due warning has been given." The warning should name "a reasonable time limit" in appropriate cases. Protection ends only once the warning "has remained unheeded." This is why the two accounts of a warning matter here. Israel said it warned the hospital, and the director said it did not.

What got buried

Whether Israel hit its target sat low or out. AP said in paragraph 2 that Abu Ismail was not among the dead. AFP said his name was missing from the civil defence list of victims. The National Post said in paragraph 6 that it was "not immediately known." Of the 32 headlines we grouped, none said the named commander was not among the dead. Reuters added in paragraph 13 that rights groups say Israel often has not shown enough evidence for such claims. Hamas did not say whether its commander was hit, Reuters reported.

Why it matters to you

Nasser serves about half of Gaza's 2 million people, Reuters reported. That is about 1 million people. Al Jazeera's reporter put it at 500,000 or more. Its surgery department and intensive care unit were badly damaged, the hospital said. The truce is about a year old. At least 1,600 Palestinians have been killed since it began, Reuters and Al Jazeera reported. AP put the figure at 1,622. AP and Reuters put Israeli deaths at 5 soldiers, while AFP counted 7 soldiers and 1 contractor. When you read about this strike, check which count each outlet uses.

The first number in a headline is a choice.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.