Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

Russia and Ukraine hold first US-mediated talks in nine months in Abu Dhabi

Day one ran nearly four hours, Zelensky called it constructive, and Europe pressed for a seat as a prisoner swap took shape.

24 outlets47 headlines3 min read
Image: Al Jazeera

The story

Russian and Ukrainian negotiators talked for nearly four hours in Abu Dhabi on Tuesday, AP reported. It was their first three-way round with the US in nine months, in a war now four and a half years old.

  • Before the talks, US officials told Fox News that both sides showed "a little bit of flexibility privately" on territory.
  • In public, Russia demands all of Donetsk and Ukraine wants the current front line frozen, Fox reported.
  • On Tuesday, November 10, US envoys Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff hosted the talks. Vladimir Medinsky led Russia's team and Rustem Umerov led Ukraine's, AP reported.
  • Secretary of State Marco Rubio, at the G7 in Paris, said the talks looked "very productive." Zelensky called them "constructive and quite substantive."
  • Kushner said he wants a framework for "decades, if not centuries, of peace," Gulf News reported. A Russian source told AFP that wider European security is a main goal.
  • Overnight, Ukraine reported 162 drones and a ballistic missile, AP said.
  • On Wednesday, both sides agreed a large prisoner exchange in principle. The Kyiv Post put it at up to 1,500 per side, Breitbart reported.
  • Sources differ on one quote. AP tied Zelensky's "constructive" to Tuesday. ABC News Australia tied it to day two.

How each side told it

The left led with Europe outside the room. Al Jazeera ran: "European diplomats press Rubio for a role in Russia-Ukraine talks." The Independent ran an opinion piece saying "lame duck Trump will only serve Putin again." Al Jazeera's wrap-up said the swap came with "no real progress." It quoted Kushner first and did not mention Rubio. HuffPost, running AP copy, led with the swap. It put Rubio's "very productive" in paragraph 16. The left gave the talks a cooler read than the officials did.

Missing context

The Times headline quotes Ukraine warning of a "second Yalta." The Yalta Conference ran from February 4 to 11, 1945, in Crimea. Franklin D. Roosevelt, Winston Churchill and Joseph Stalin attended. The US and Britain generally agreed that postwar governments in Eastern European nations bordering the Soviet Union should be "friendly" to it. The Soviets pledged free elections in lands freed from Nazi Germany. A declaration on Poland provided for Communists in its postwar government. Source: US Office of the Historian, "The Yalta Conference, 1945."

What got buried

The people behind the swap got little space. Breitbart, in paragraph 11, cited UN figures of more than 10,000 prisoners of war held by both sides. It added 16,000 Ukrainian civilians the UN considers unlawfully detained by Russia. In the seven reports we read on these talks, only Breitbart gave those figures. A second detail sat low too. Fox reported in paragraph 19 that sanctions could ease as leverage. They would "spring back in place" if Moscow broke a deal, Fox said.

Why it matters to you

Take the swap math. Up to 1,500 people per side means up to 3,000 people in total. The UN counts more than 10,000 prisoners of war. So this one swap would free at most about 30% of them. TASS said it would happen within two to three weeks, Al Jazeera reported. The drone war kept running during the talks. Drone debris set fire to Russia's Ust-Luga oil export port and injured 3 workers, ABC News Australia reported. The reports we read gave no figures on prices or markets. You can track the swap date as a plain test of whether the talks deliver.

A handshake is news, and a prisoner count is proof.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.