Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

Pope Leo tells Milei 'the economy must serve the person' on first visit to Argentina

On the first papal visit in nearly 40 years, Leo pressed on jobs, pensions and young people leaving. Milei's government said it governs for tomorrow's Argentines.

14 outlets19 headlines2 min read
Image: AP (via ABC30)

The story

Argentina's inflation fell from 200% to about 32% under Javier Milei, while about 300,000 formal jobs vanished, AP reported. On November 8, Pope Leo XIV arrived and spoke to both.

  • Leo arrived from Uruguay on Sunday, November 8. It is the first papal visit to Argentina in nearly 40 years, AP reported.
  • Milei spoke first at the Palacio Libertad. His government says it avoids "punishing the Argentines of tomorrow" to help those of today, AFP reported.
  • Then Leo said: "The economy must serve the person, not the person the economy."
  • He spoke of people who "despite hard work, nonetheless struggle to meet their household's needs." He also urged support for whatever "stimulates private initiative," AP reported.
  • He said rulers must "recognise the limits of the power entrusted to them," the Buenos Aires Times reported. He never named Milei.
  • On young people, he said a nation must ask "where it has failed when its young people have to leave."
  • Milei once called Pope Francis the "representative of evil on Earth." On Sunday he called Francis "the most important Argentine in history," AP reported.
  • Poverty reached 32.3% in September, AFP reported. The average pension is $510 a month, and university funding is down about 40% since 2023, AP reported.
  • On Monday, Leo visited a care home for disabled people in Claypole. He called their lives a blessing.

How each side told it

Left-leaning outlets framed a clash. The Guardian ran "Pope's visit to Argentina sets up showdown with 'hyper-capitalist' Milei." CNN ran "Pope Leo urges President Milei, a Trump ally, to 'safeguard democracy'." The Washington Post called it a "veiled rebuke of austerity measures." CNN put Milei's tie to Trump in its headline. The phrase "safeguard democracy" did not appear in the reports we read. Leo spoke of the "careful use of words" and of seeing opponents "as fellow citizens."

What got buried

Two things got less room than the rebuke. First, Leo backed private initiative, which AP reported in paragraph 11. Second, he never named Milei, the Buenos Aires Times noted. The same paper said Milei's government avoided any political reading of the speeches. AP also put Milei's results, a budget surplus and inflation down to about 32%, in one paragraph with the 300,000 lost jobs. Most headlines we read used "rebuke," "showdown" or "criticises" and left out the praise.

Why it matters to you

The two numbers pull in opposite ways, and both are real. At 200% inflation, a basket costing 1,000 pesos would cost 3,000 a year later. At about 32%, the same basket would cost about 1,320. That is our math from AP's figures. Real wages are still below their level from late 2023, AP reported. Retirees, on an average pension of $510 a month, have protested every Wednesday for more than two years. You can hold both facts at once. Leo's speech did the same, in gentler words.

Two true numbers can tell opposite stories.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.